Catholic Church -- Controversial literature -- Protestant authors; Popes -- Infallibility
A CHARGE delivered to the CLERGY of the ARCHDEACONRY of Middlesex, in
1843.
VIII.
A CHARGE delivered in 1844.
IX.
A CHARGE delivered in 1849.
SIDE NOTES.
In the printed book Rev. Sinclair printed side notes in the margins to
explain the points he was trying to make. As these made the text itself
difficult to read, and added little value to the narrative, in this
transcription they are placed here, together with the pages on which they
occur, so that the development of the points can be seen in overview.
Side note Page
Diversity of religious opinions a source of anxiety 1
On account of others and on our own 1
Confusion from the number of guides 2
Motives of credibility for an infallible living arbiter 2
Fallacy and presumption of these _à priori_ arguments 3
Probable arguments at best are no ground of infallible 5
assurance
Argument for infallibility from the analogy of the Jewish 6
Church
. . . answered 6
Transmission of the Scripture no proof of infallible 8
interpretation
Three requisites to afford us infallible assurance 8
First requisite wanting. Organ of infallibility uncertain 9
Second requisite wanting in the Three Organs of 11
infallibility. The Pope singly
Pretensions of the Pontiff scripturally considered 11
Pretensions of the Pontiff traditionally considered 14
Pretensions of the Pontiff morally considered 18
Difficulties of ascertaining infallibly when the Pope 19
speaks _ex cathedrâ_
Papal inconsistencies and heresies 20
Second alleged Organ of Infallibility 21
A general council singly 22
Pretensions of a general council Scripturally considered 22
Difficulties of knowing what is a general council 25
Third organ of infallibility 25
Pope and general council in conjunction 26
Uncertainty of the Papal sanction to a council 26
Additional argument against Popes and Councils jointly 27
Third requisite to afford infallible assurance. This 28
requisite wanting
Theory of Development 31
Right path to saving knowledge 32
Difference of this Scriptural principle from the three 33
preceding
Rules for acquiring sound Christian knowledge 33
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account