An Essay on the Lyric Poetry of the AncientsOgilvie, John
History
An Essay on the Lyric Poetry of the Ancients
Ogilvie, John
Classical poetry -- History and criticism
[Footnote 83: Upon the principle established here, we may account
in some measure for Voltaire’s apparently paradoxical assertion,
with regard to the comparative merit of Homer and Tasso. The
Italian (says that spirited writer) has more conduct, variety and
justness than the Greek. Admitting the truth of this reflection,
we might still reply, that the principal merit of the Iliad,
considered as the production of Genius, lies in the grandeur of
the sentiments, the beauty and sublimity of the illustrations, and
the _original_ strokes which are wrought into the description of
the _principal Actors_. In all these respects we may venture to
affirm, that Homer remains without a superior among Authors
unaided by Inspiration; and the reader must be left to judge
whether or not it is from these criterions that we estimate the
Genius of a Poet. Our Author proceeds upon the same principles to
compare the Orlando Furioso with the Odyssey, and give a
preference to the former. The merit of these works may be
ascertained in some measure, by the rules we have already
established. We need only to add further on this head, that among
many beauties we meet with examples of the turgid and bombast in
the work of Ariosto; from which that of the Greek Poet is wholly
free. The two first lines of his Poem,
_Le Donne, e Cavalieri, l’arme, gli amore,
Le Cortesie l’audaci impresi io canto._
if they do not put one in mind of the Cyclic Writer mentioned by
Horace, who begins his Poem with
_Fortunam Priami cantabo, & nobile bellum._
yet are of a very different strain from those which introduce the
Odyssey,
Ανδρα μοι ενεπε Μουσα πολυτροπον, ὅς μαλα πολλα
Πλαγκθη &c.
I cannot help thinking that the whole of this introduction is
remarkably simple and unornamented, though a very judicious and
ingenious Critic seems to be of a contrary opinion.]
The noblest instances of this personification are to be found in the
Sacred Writings. Nothing can exceed the majesty, with which the descent
of the Almighty is described by the Prophet Habakkuk. “Before Him (he
tells us) went the Pestilence, &c.” then suddenly addressing the Deity
in the second person, he says “the Mountains _saw Thee_, and they
_trembled_, the Overflowing of the waters _passed by_, the _Deep uttered
his voice_, and _lift up his hands_ on high[84].” In another place, the
Deluge is nobly animated, in order to display the Omnipotence of God.
“The waters (says the Psalmist) stood above the mountains. At thy rebuke
they _fled_, at the voice of thy thunder they _hasted away_.”
[Footnote 84: Hab. ch. iii. v. 3.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account