Ancient calendars and constellationsPlunket, Emmeline M. (Emmeline Mary)
History
Ancient calendars and constellations
Plunket, Emmeline M. (Emmeline Mary)
Astronomy, Ancient; Calendar; Constellations
[100] The 28 Siou are not of equal extent, and there are many
discrepancies in the Chinese tables which profess to give the number
of degrees attributed to each. In the diagram, therefore, only the
stars which compose the three adjoining domiciles, Niu, Hiu, and Wei
are noted, and they are connected by straight lines, according to
Chinese astronomical custom.
There is in the great History of China a description given of a
reformation of the calendar carried out by the Emperor Tchuen-Hio,
whose date is placed at 2510-2431 B.C. The conjunction of the sun and
moon close to the Siou Hiu is in this description clearly referred to
as a mark given for the beginning of the year. But the fact of this
choice of the star mark Hiu has, for European scholars, been obscured
by a most unfortunate paraphrase made use of by Père de Mailla, the
translator into French of the _Histoire Générale de la Chine_. He gives
us in the passage describing Tchuen-Hio’s reformation the phrase, “15°
du Verseau,” instead of the Chinese expression, “the Siou Hiu.”[101]
[101] The fact that P. de Mailla has so paraphrased the Chinese
original has thus plainly been attested by the late Professor Legge.
In answer to a question addressed to him on the subject, he wrote,
in December 1894, to Mr. H. W. Greene, Fellow of Magdalen College,
Oxford, as follows: “In the passage from P. de Mailla’s History, that
writer is both translating and paraphrasing ‘the star group Hiu.’”
[Illustration: PLATE XIV.
Domiciles Niu, Hiu and Wei, of the Chinese Lunar Zodiac.]
The Siou Hiu extends over some eight or ten degrees of the ecliptic in
the constellation Aquarius; to restrict to _one_ degree the given star
mark was an inaccuracy serious enough in an astronomical statement, but
this inaccuracy is as nothing when compared with the further entire
distortion of facts occasioned by P. de Mailla’s use of the ambiguous
phrase, “15° du Verseau,” ambiguous because it can be taken to refer
either to the fifteenth degree of the _sign_, or of the _constellation_
“du Verseau” (Aquarius).
The Siou Hiu is situated, as stated above, in the _constellation_
Aquarius (see diagram), but astronomers reading P. de Mailla’s
translation have understood the phrase in its technical sense, and have
therefore been led to believe that the Emperor Tchuen-Hio fixed the
beginning of the Chinese year to the 15° of the _sign_ Aquarius; and
as, astronomically and technically speaking, the 15° Aquarius (sign)
has no reference to any star or constellation, but is only that point
of the ecliptic to which the sun attains exactly at the mid-season
between winter solstice and spring equinox, they have taken for granted
that 2,500 B.C. the Chinese year began at that point, and therefore at
the same season as it does at the present time.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account