Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Classical literature -- History and criticism -- Theory, etc.; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Ancient
(viii) Of such heightening (1) the first and strongest
source is intellectual power of conception; (2) the second,
emotion. These are native; the remaining three are acquired:
(3) handling of figures, (4) noble diction, and (5), what
includes the other two, sentence movement (_compositio_).
(ix) The force of the first (i.e., conception), and also
its waning, we feel in Homer, whose _Odyssey_ lapses into
narrative from the dramatic power of the _Iliad_. (x) The
realization of this first source in actual composition means
compression, the bringing together of significances with no
insignificances to interrupt. (xi) Oratorical amplification,
which is complementary to this, of itself never rises to the
heights. (xii) Heightening of style is single and intensive, as
in poetry or in the orations of Demosthenes; amplification is
iterative and extensive, as in Plato or Cicero. (xiii) Plato,
however, shows the way to mastery—imitation, (xiv) a way which
even we may follow.
_The second source is emotion._ (This is not treated here in
its place as a separate section, but is implied throughout what
follows.)
_The third source is handling of figures._
(xv) For weight, grandeur, and energy the right language
is imagery. In oratory the purpose of this typically is
intellectual; in poetry, emotional; but oratory too may use
it for emotional effect. [xvi-xxix. Discussion of figures.]
(xxx-xxxi) Beautiful words are essentially the light of
thought; and homely words have their expressiveness. (xxxii)
Abundance of figurative language may proceed from emotion
and kindle it. Even extended and detailed metaphor may be
stimulating.
_The fourth source, noble diction, means more than constant
excellence._
(xxxiii) Better eminence with some faults than a lower
plane without them: Homer than Apollonius, Archilochus than
Eratosthenes, Pindar than Bacchylides, Sophocles than Ion,
(xxxiv) Demosthenes than Hyperides, (xxxv) Plato than Lysias,
and, in general, force than elegance. (xxxvi) But though the
achievement due to art is typically that of the lower plane,
the success of never failing, the assurance of technical
mastery, still this does not make art the less important.
[xxxvii-xxxviii. Further on figures: metaphor, hyperbole.]
_The fifth source is sentence movement (compositio)._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account