Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Classical literature -- History and criticism -- Theory, etc.; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Ancient
It is a larger achievement, one of the greatest,[24] to heighten epic
by suggesting vast reaches of time, from tribal wanderings through wars
of conquest to the reign of law. Here is the artistic significance of
the visit in Book VI to the world of the dead and the unborn, which,
as Mackail says, “slips in the keystone.” To compare the visit of
Odysseus to the shades is to see Vergil’s higher art of composition. But
the suggestion of the great loom of time (_tot volvere casus_) is not
confined to a single artistic device; it is pervasive from the opening
words through a hundred careful allusions; and it makes the _Æneid_ wider
than the _Iliad_ or the _Odyssey_ by making it constantly suggestive of
the whole struggle of history. It reveals more explicitly the struggles
of heroic men as the struggle of man.
Thus the oft-repeated objection that the _Æneid_ breaks into halves is
superficial. The break would not have been thought of if Vergil had
not been seen to be working for a continuity stricter than Homer’s.
Stated baldly by Tyrrell, the idea that the _Æneid_ is an _Odyssey_
plus an _Iliad_ presupposes a sort of imitation to which Vergil shows
himself everywhere superior. It would be as near the truth to reply
that the _Æneid_ is neither an _Odyssey_ nor an _Iliad_. But prototypes
aside, how and how far is the _Æneid_ held together? Surely by the most
careful articulation ever seen in epic, but surely not to the degree
of drama. Among the evidences of revision are indications that the
plan for the wanderings of Æneas was first achieved[25] when much of
the poem was already written. The adjustment of this part to the whole
course, a technic hardly explored by Homer, and the abbreviations of the
wanderings by careful selection, are of a piece with the consistent
connection by repetition of the theme, from the opening lines,
Trojæ qui primus ab oris
Italiam, fato profugus,
throughout the whole poem. True, the seventh book invokes Erato for
scenes of battle.
Maior rerum mihi nascitur ordo;
Maius opus moveo.
The following scenes are different, but not the theme. The art that
deliberately avoided Homer’s succession of battles by interposing such
scenes as Evander’s achieved more than variety. It suggests again
and again what the battles were for. The close upon the tragic death
of Turnus becomes more than the personal victory of the hero; it is
the triumph, over _violentia_, over such individual prowess as Homer
glorified, over personal ambition thwarting the state, of fortitude
bringing in religion and law.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account