Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Classical literature -- History and criticism -- Theory, etc.; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Ancient
Distinguishing[26] charm (ἡδονή) from beauty (τὸ καλόν), Dionysius
finds[27] that they arise from four qualities: melody, rhythm, variety,
aptness. Melody is an affair of pitch and inflection. The passage,[28]
besides being a precious hint as to the Greek scale, is a useful reminder
that English—and especially American—speech too often ignores variety
of pitch. Similarly the treatment of rhythm as quantitative[29] should
remind us that in our own habit it is predominantly accentual. These
differences in habit of speech, while they suggest resources unused,
should none the less warn us against transferring the distinctions
and counsels of Dionysius bodily from Greek to English. Of those that
are equally applicable to both languages is the general advice[30] to
seek variety and aptness less in the choice of words, where there can
be little latitude, than in their combination. Indeed, it is hardly
too much to say that aptness of style, though abstractly it includes
precision and imagery in the single word, is more largely than most of
us realize an effect of rhythm, and that variety, except when in oral
utterance it includes pitch, consists in rhythm exclusively.
Distinguishing[31] the letters as vowels or consonants, Dionysius finds
Greek speech sounds to be neither more nor less than twenty-four. His
phonetic analysis of these is specifically according to the position
of the vocal organs in utterance. The following discussion[32] of the
quality of syllables in combination, of effects hard, smooth, or sweet
in sound apart from sense, is doctrine oftener accepted as an idea than
tested.[33]
Syllables, which are combinations or interweavings of letters,
preserve at once both the individual properties of each
component and the joint properties of all, which spring from
their fusion and juxtaposition. The sounds thus formed are soft
or hard, smooth or rough, sweet to the ear or harsh to it; they
make us pull a wry face, or cause our mouths to water, or bring
about any of the countless other physical conditions that are
possible.
These facts the greatest poets and prose-writers have carefully
noted, and not only do they carefully arrange their words and
weave them into appropriate patterns, but often, with curious
and loving skill, they adapt the very syllables and letters to
the emotions which they wish to represent.
[Passages from Homer are quoted as examples.]
Such lines are to be found without number in Homer,
representing length of time, hugeness of body, stress of
emotion, immobility of position, or similar effects, simply by
the manipulation of the syllables. Conversely others are framed
to give the impression of abruptness, speed, hurry, and the
like.[34]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account