Ancient Rome and Modern America; A Comparative Study of Morals and MannersFerrero, Guglielmo
History
Ancient Rome and Modern America; A Comparative Study of Morals and Manners
Ferrero, Guglielmo
America -- Civilization; Europe -- Civilization; Justice, Administration of -- Rome; Progress
On the other hand, this reproach, which, couched in its usual form, is
unjust, contains a modicum of truth, which however applies to Europe
as well as to America. I have often had occasion to notice in wealthy
modern houses—in Europe as well as in America, but in America more
than in Europe—that they are adorned with many extremely beautiful old
pieces, but that these are too numerous, and too heterogeneous. You
find in a modern drawing-room material of every epoch and from all
parts of the world; from ancient Greece, and from China of the last
century, from the Italian Middle Ages and from contemporary Persia.
Consequently modern houses are too much like small museums, in which
numbers of wonderful little antiques, picked up wherever they were to
be had, are exposed to view, and in which the modern furniture and
adornments serve as the show-case in which the antiques are displayed,
instead of being, as they were in the eighteenth century, the principal
decoration, of which some beautiful antique was the appropriate
ornament and complement. This inversion of the natural order of things
would be inexplicable, were we not all of us persuaded more or less
consciously that old things must necessarily be more beautiful than
modern ones. For this reason we are willing that what we make, the
modern, shall be subordinated and serve as a tool to the antique.
In short, the antique, in Europe as in America, has acquired nowadays a
value of its own in art, merely on the score of its antiquity. I need
not dwell on the strangeness of this prejudice in favour of antiques
in an age and in countries in which, directly one leaves the field
of art behind, one finds so keen a craze for the modern. Not to be
up-to-date is at the present day the greatest reproach we can fling at
a man in Europe and in America, especially in America. Why then does
modernity in art arouse, not only in old Europe, but also, and perhaps
more, in young America, so much diffidence and mistrust? Why do we,
notwithstanding the attempts which modern artists make to emulate the
ancients or to create new things, turn to the past when we want to
possess or enjoy something really beautiful? May this contradiction
be the effort of a last surviving prejudice? For centuries, man was
educated to consider all antique things, only because they were
antique, preferable to modern ones. In many respects, we have conquered
this venerable prejudice. May our attachment to the antique in art
be the last and most persistent survival of this sentiment, itself
destined to disappear?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account