Ancient Rome and Modern America; A Comparative Study of Morals and MannersFerrero, Guglielmo
History
Ancient Rome and Modern America; A Comparative Study of Morals and Manners
Ferrero, Guglielmo
America -- Civilization; Europe -- Civilization; Justice, Administration of -- Rome; Progress
Lastly, I could explain why in American society, to borrow a rather
quaint philosophical expression, the category of quantity prevails
over that of quality. During my first few weeks in America, I used to
smile when I heard some Americans go into ecstasies at the thought
that everything in America was big, from the country to the cities,
the factories, and the statistics of population; when they gloated
over comparisons between their own country and the little countries of
Europe, and statements of the comparative superiority in size of things
in their own country. I no longer smiled, however, when I realised
what American progress represented. A civilisation, whose principal
instrument for the accomplishment of its work and for establishing
itself in the world is machinery, must necessarily consider the
quantitative criterion the supreme criterion of perfection. In what
respect, indeed, is machinery, regarded as an instrument of production,
superior to the human hand? Everybody knows that its superiority
consists not in quality, but in the quantity, of its output. Machinery
produces much and quickly. The hand produces little and slowly. The
hand, however, can attain a standard of perfection which is denied
machinery. Man will never succeed in constructing a machine capable
of sculpturing the Venus of Milo or of weaving the marvellous
tapestries which we admire in the museums of Europe. Everything of
a high degree of perfection is exclusively handmade; _vice versa_,
the hand, however, it may strive and labour and practise, will never
succeed in attaining in its work the giddy rapidity of which steam-
and electricity-driven machines are capable, or in producing in so
short a time so many good things. Consequently, in a civilisation in
which machinery predominates, men will be continually making fresh
efforts to live faster and faster, and to produce and consume more
and more rapidly. They will not be, on the other hand, too exacting
on the score of quality. They will be content with things which look
nice, without demanding extraordinary excellence or finish in details.
They will be better pleased to consume many examples of products of
inferior durability than one single example of products of great
perfection. Consequently, vagaries of taste, continual movement,
ready forgetfulness of traditions, and abundance of mediocrity, will
be salient characteristics of machine-ruled civilisation. The great
works of art which were the glory of past régimes will disappear for
the present, which will see them replaced by objects of medium quality
offered in greater quantity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account