As in former years in my annual summary in the _Boston Transcript_, I
have examined the contents of the leading American magazines. To the
seven magazines which I examined last year,--namely, _Harper’s_,
_Scribner’s_, _The Century_, _The Forum_, _Lippincott’s_, _The Smart
Set_, and _The Bellman_,--I have added this year three monthlies, _The
Trend_, _The International_, and _The Masses_; and one quarterly, _The
Yale Review_. _The Bellman_ still maintains its high poetic distinction,
by virtue of which it prints more good poetry than any other American
weekly, and most American monthlies. As last year, I have winnowed from
other magazines distinctive poems for classification and notice:--one
each from _The Metropolitan_, _The Craftsman_, _The Poetry Journal_, the
_Southern Woman’s Magazine_, _Puck_, and _The Infantry Journal_; and two
each from _Poetry: A Magazine of Verse_, _The Nation_, _The Atlantic
Monthly_, and the _Outlook_; while from three newspapers I have selected
fourteen poems:--eleven from the _Boston Evening Transcript_, two from
the _Boston News Bureau_, and one from the _New York Evening Sun_. In
quoting from the _Boston Transcript_, I wish to testify to the ready
recognition and encouragement this daily paper has offered to poets and
poetry. It is one of the paper’s finest traditions.
The poems published during the year in the eleven representative
magazines I have submitted to an impartial critical test, choosing from
the total number what I consider the “distinctive” poems of the year.
From the distinctive pieces are selected fifty-two poems, to which are
added thirty from other magazines and from newspapers not represented in
the list of eleven, making a total of eighty-two, which are intended to
represent what I call an “Anthology of Magazine Verse for 1914.”
Quoting from what I have written in previous years, to emphasize the
methods which guided my selections, the reader will see how impartial
are the tests by which the distinctive and best poems are chosen: “I
have not allowed any special sympathy with the subject to influence my
choice. I have taken the poet’s point of view, and accepted his value of
the theme he dealt with. The question was: How vital and compelling did
he make it? The first test was the sense of pleasure the poem
communicated; then to discover the secret or the meaning of the pleasure
felt; and in doing so to realize how much richer one became in a
knowledge of the purpose of life by reason of the poem’s message.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account