Apollonius : $b or, The present and future of psychical researchBennett, E. N. (Ernest Nathaniel), Sir
Science
Apollonius : $b or, The present and future of psychical research
Bennett, E. N. (Ernest Nathaniel), Sir
Parapsychology
We need not devote much time to the deliberate fraud and trickery
which have always been admittedly associated with certain manifestations
of mediumship and have frequently inspired such disgust and contempt in
the minds of would-be investigators that they have abandoned the quest
altogether. Those who have persevered in spite of discouragement know
what it is to find oneself in uncomfortable and ill-ventilated rooms,
holding the hands of unknown persons in the dark, tortured by the
metallic music of a cheap gramophone, or compelled to join in discordant
renderings of revivalist hymns or dreadful ditties like “Where is now
the prophet Daniel?” And one realizes all the time that the music is
meant to drown the noise caused by a fraudulent medium in wrapping
himself in muslin or adjusting a false beard, and further that one will
have to pay a guinea for this wretched exhibition! What researcher,
again, has not experienced the boredom of public or private sittings for
“delineations”, when a medium, after a few spasmodic twitchings, “passes
under control” and proceeds to describe the appearance of the deceased
relatives and friends of the members of a credulous audience, which will
subsequently contribute to the “silver collection”? Who, too, has not
reflected with amazement upon the staggering credulity of men and women
who accept the delineated “old gentleman with white hair” or the “old
lady with grey hair parted in the middle” as unquestionably their late
father or mother; or, in a materializing _séance_, believe that the same
piece of butter muslin waved in one direction is a lost grandparent and
waved in another direction is a little child? Such wearisome and sordid
experiences form the _via dolorosa_ of researchers, who are prepared
to seek for gold even in the muddiest streams, and sometimes find
it; for, even if ninety-five per cent. of the alleged phenomena are
explicable by trickery or deception, the remaining five may defy all
such explanations.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account