Apollonius : $b or, The present and future of psychical research — John Shaqi
Apollonius : $b or, The present and future of psychical researchBennett, E. N. (Ernest Nathaniel), Sir
Science
Apollonius : $b or, The present and future of psychical research
Bennett, E. N. (Ernest Nathaniel), Sir
Parapsychology
Apart from the more or less unintelligent prejudices of the public
generally, the scientific investigation of the phenomena of mediumship
is hampered by the professional antagonisms of the Church and the Law.
The menace of legal proceedings, while a terror to the fraudulent,
is also a deterrent to the supply of genuine phenomena. Mediums are
usually persons of a very sensitive and nervous temperament, and
the fact that at any moment a Mrs Leonard is liable to the same
legal procedure and the same conviction as the most insignificant
fortune-teller is not conducive to the regular supply of those
supernormal facts which form the subject-matter of scientific psychical
research. From time to time, and apparently by concerted action, legal
proceedings are set on foot by the authorities against public mediums.
The requisite evidence is furnished by detectives or journalists
who have secured sittings with the defendants, and the prosecution
takes place under an Act of George IV, directed against “vagabonds”
and “fortune-tellers”. Our magistrates usually maintain on these
occasions that the essential part of the legal offence is the medium’s
claim to “foretell the future”, and this is apparently accentuated
and aggravated by the “intention to deceive” or the acceptance of
money or reward. During an epidemic of legal medium-baiting in
1917, men and women were sentenced to heavy fines, up to £50, or
imprisonment, because of their claims to foretell the future. Yet
a little reflection might have caused our magistrates to remember
that all the official representatives of organized religion are
regularly engaged in foretelling the future and are paid――and quite
rightly――for their services in this respect. The so-called “sport”
of the race-course is――as many of us know to our cost――built upon an
elaborate and extensive system of prophecy for payment――whether the
forecasts are made in the columns of the most respectable newspapers
or in the circulars of professional tipsters. Nor, indeed, can one
wholly dissociate those manifold pledges which disfigure our political
elections from the same suspicion; for these prophetic anticipations
are made in order to win votes and so secure the social and pecuniary
rewards which result from electoral success.
Some of the magistrates who tried and condemned these mediums displayed
a pitiable ignorance of the whole subject of psychic phenomena. Almost
anybody indeed appears to be considered competent to dogmatize about
theological or psychic matters without any credentials in the shape
of adequate study or experience. The following extract from the well
known “Brockway” case serves to illustrate the mental equipment of a
magistrate for a trial of this character:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account