Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuriesHitchcock, Henry-Russell
History
Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuries
Hitchcock, Henry-Russell
Architecture, Modern -- 19th century; Architecture, Modern -- 20th century
In Scotland, where Greek sanctions lasted longer than in England,
Alexander Thomson (1817-75) built in the fifties and sixties three of
the finest Romantic Classical churches in the world. His Caledonia Road
Free Church in Glasgow of 1856-7 was designed for those Presbyterians
who had left the established Scottish church in 1843 (Plate 29). This
owes a great deal to Schinkel’s suburban Berlin churches, which Thomson
must have known through the _Sammlung architektonischer Entwürfe_. The
composition is more Picturesque, in being markedly asymmetrical, and the
superb tower at the corner reduces the temple front to a subordinate
element in a sort of Italian Villa composition. Yet the idea for this
sort of composition may well have come from Schinkel also, a derivation
which the rather _Rundbogenstil_ character and asymmetrical organization
of certain of Thomson’s earlier suburban villas seems to make still more
probable. The interior of the church is very different from that of
Soane’s in Walworth, but it is equally architectonic in the
Schinkelesque way the galleries are incorporated in the general scheme.
This is real interior architecture, not just a gallery-surrounded hall
like the Grecian churches in England built back in the twenties.
Thomson’s more prominently located St Vincent Street Church of 1859,
also in Glasgow, is not finer. But it utilizes a difficult site with
striking success, and the exotic eclecticism of the spire is peculiarly
personal to Thomson. His Queen’s Park Church of 1867, in a southern
suburb of Glasgow, was as perversely original as anything by Soane, and
is perhaps Thomson’s final masterpiece. Inside, he handled the light
iron supports with clear logic and elegantly appropriate painted
decoration. Both the heavy masonry tower—which is, of course, invisible
from the interior—and the heavy clerestory are carried on these
delicately proportioned metal columns with a frankness and boldness
hardly equalled before the twentieth century. Externally Thomson
detailed the trabeated masonry with the purity of a Schinkel and the
originality of a Soane, yet he composed the façade in three dimensions
in a fashion that is almost Baroque beneath his strange near-Hindu
‘spire’.
Thomson’s churches, late though they are, can be better understood as
examples of Romantic Classicism, sharing important qualities with the
boldest French projects of the 1780s, than in relation to any other
stage of nineteenth-century architectural development. Yet it will be
evident later that they also have a good deal in common with the
architectural aspirations of their own quarter of the century (see
Chapter 9).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account