Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuriesHitchcock, Henry-Russell
History
Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuries
Hitchcock, Henry-Russell
Architecture, Modern -- 19th century; Architecture, Modern -- 20th century
E. M. Barry went on to crown two London station hotels, that at Charing
Cross in 1863-4 and that at Cannon Street in 1865-6, with mansards; but
these were far from being masterpieces, and that at Charing Cross has
lately been much modified. The Grosvenor Hotel, built beside the new
Victoria Station in 1859-60 by Sir James T. Knowles (1831-1908), is far
more original. He covered the whole enormous mass with a very tall
convex mansard, giving further emphasis to the broad pavilions at the
ends by carrying their roofs still higher and capping them with
lanterns. Beyond this nothing was French. The detail indeed, defined by
its architect as ‘Tuscan’, i.e. _Rundbogenstil_, is highly individual,
partaking of the coarse gusto and even somewhat of the naturalism of the
most advanced Victorian Gothic foliage carving of the period (see
Chapter 10).
Similar mansards, but flat-sided not bulbous, and similar detail
characterize a pair of tall terraces that Knowles built in 1860 on the
north side of Clapham Common, south of London. These constituted a
subtle suburban attack on Early Victorian traditions of terrace-design
that soon had metropolitan repercussions. His Thatched House Club in St
James’s Street in London of 1865 has a great deal of very rich carving
by J. Daymond in the naturalistic vein, but is less interesting in
general composition.
Knowles’s Grosvenor was still new when John Giles outbid it with the
Langham Hotel, begun in 1864. Given a much finer site than Knowles’s at
the base of the broad avenue of Portland Place across from Nash’s All
Souls’, Langham Place, Giles rose boldly—most people now think too
boldly—to the occasion (Plate 80A). Certainly he overwhelmed Nash’s
delicate and ingenious steeple by the rounded projection and the tall
square corner tower—now bombed away at the top—with which he faced it.
Equally certainly his massive north façade, with its boldly modelled
flanking pavilions and its profusion of lively animal carvings, would
overwhelm the urbane refinement of the nearby Adam terraces flanking
Portland Place had these not by now been replaced by far inferior
buildings. For all its gargantuan scale and the somewhat elephantine
playfulness of the detail (not to speak of the dinginess to which the
‘Suffolk-white’ brickwork and the stone trim have now been reduced), the
Langham is a rich and powerfully plastic composition, most skilfully
adapted to a special site, and more original than most of what was
produced in the sixties in Paris. The carved animals at the window
heads, so varied and so humorous, deserve an attention they rarely
receive; these scurrying creatures almost seem to come out of Tenniel,
but may actually derive from Viollet-le-Duc.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account