Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuriesHitchcock, Henry-Russell
History
Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuries
Hitchcock, Henry-Russell
Architecture, Modern -- 19th century; Architecture, Modern -- 20th century
For Trinity College in Hartford, Conn., Burges prepared in 1873 a
splendid plan worthy of its fine new site on a high ridge south of the
city (Plate 88). Unfortunately only one side of one quadrangle was
finished according to his designs; but that is perhaps the most
satisfactory of all his works, and the best example anywhere of
Victorian Gothic collegiate architecture. The brownstone from nearby
Portland, Conn., favourite material all over the eastern states during
what Lewis Mumford has called the ‘Brown Decades’, is especially well
suited to Burges’s heavy and well-articulated detail. The rough
quarry-facing of the random ashlar contrasts tonally with the more
smoothly cut trim in a fashion that is polytonal if not polychromatic.
The roughness of the stone walls also enhances the massive proportions
of the long dormitory range and of the paired towers with their boldly
pyramidal roofs. Yet for the classrooms this masonry is articulated into
banks of large mullioned windows. Despite the general regularity and
even symmetry of the composition, there is plenty of functionally
logical variety in the handling of the different sections. Burges was
happy in the Scottish-born Hartford architect who supervised the work,
G. W. Keller (1842-1935); and Keller revealed his continued debt to
Burges in the construction of a Memorial Arch in the park in Hartford
which is one of the very few examples of such a Classical monument
completely translated into Gothic terms, and not without real interest.
Burges undoubtedly enjoyed more what he did for the Marquess of Bute,
beginning in 1865, in restoring Cardiff Castle and Castell Coch in
Wales. ‘Restoring’ should be put in quotation marks, for by the time
Burges got through with them both were almost as much fake castles as
any built in the first half of the century. They lie somewhere between
Fonthill Abbey and Peckforton in intention and are considerably more
sumptuous internally than either. Although Cardiff Castle, which had
been subjected to drastic Georgian remodelling, was gradually
re-castellated with considerable consistency, the work there never
reached completion. It is chiefly the incredibly rich interiors that are
of interest, even if the interest is of a rather theatrical order.
Castell Coch near Llandaff, restored in 1875, interiors of equal
fantasy, almost comparable to those of Neuschwanstein; that is,
they are more like settings for Wagnerian opera than anything the
Middle Ages actually created. But the quality of the imagination
and of the execution is of a very much higher order than Ludwig II
commanded. Externally Castell Coch is a sober and plausible
restoration-reconstruction of a smallish castle, chiefly of
archaeological interest, but most romantically sited and solidly
built. Beside its integrity the more famous restorations by
Viollet-le-Duc at Pierrefonds and Carcassonne appear rather harsh,
and obviously modern.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account