Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuriesHitchcock, Henry-Russell
History
Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuries
Hitchcock, Henry-Russell
Architecture, Modern -- 19th century; Architecture, Modern -- 20th century
The McConochie house, built in Cardiff for Lord Bute’s estate agent, is
one of the best medium-sized stone dwellings of the High Victorian
Gothic, superior in almost every way to Burges’s own house at 9 Melbury
Road in London. That was built later, in 1875-80, by which time the
operatic medievalism of the interiors was quite out of date (see Chapter
12). Here in the Cardiff house the tight asymmetrical composition, the
excellent detailing of the handsome stonework, and a generally domestic
rather than Castellated air prepared the way for Burges’s fine
collegiate work in America.
English architects in the sixties were capable of exploiting a wide
range of different aspects of the High Victorian Gothic in almost
precisely the same years. Only the size and departmentalized
organization of G. G. Scott’s office, the largest of the period and more
like the ‘plan-factories’ of the twentieth century (see Chapter 24), can
explain how he could be nominally responsible for such a quiet,
well-scaled, and advanced church as St Andrew’s, Derby, designed in
1866—some say by Micklethwaite, who was working for him at the time—and
also for such a strident, complex, and over-elaborated edifice as the
Midland Hotel fronting St Pancras Station. The design for this was
prepared in 1865 for a competition held, curiously enough, two years
after the shed had been begun by the engineers W. H. Barlow (1812-1902)
and R. M. Ordish (1824-86). Such a drastic divorce of engineering and
architecture could hardly be expected to produce a co-ordinated edifice,
yet both aspects of St Pancras have considerable independent interest.
The shed, ingeniously tied below the level of the tracks and rising, for
purely coincidental technical reasons, to a flattened point of slightly
‘Gothic’ outline, has the widest span of any in the British Isles and,
until the nineties, in the world. It is, therefore, a nineteenth-century
spatial achievement of quantitative, if not so much of qualitative,
significance. The masonry block at the front is one of the largest High
Victorian Gothic structures in the world. It long had ardent admirers,
and it has come to have them again, for it epitomizes almost as notably
as the Albert Memorial the aspirations of Scott and his generation. The
contrast to its neighbour, Lewis Cubitt’s Kings Cross Station, begun
some fifteen years earlier, or even to Paddington, where the engineer
Brunel and the architect Wyatt collaborated so happily, is striking. The
taste of English railway authorities, as of most patrons of
architecture, had been revolutionized by the general triumph of the High
Victorian Gothic in the late fifties and early sixties. Yet on its
completion in the mid seventies St Pancras was even more out of fashion
in advanced circles than were Street’s Law Courts, the construction of
which only began at that time, so rapidly did taste continue to change
in the late sixties and early seventies.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account