Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and DarwinBall, W. P. (William Platt)
Philosophy
Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and Darwin
Ball, W. P. (William Platt)
Heredity; Variation (Biology)
Mr. Spencer thinks that the non-transmission of acquired modifications
is incongruous with the great fact of atavism. But the great law of the
inheritance of that which is a development of the transmissible type
does not necessarily imply the inheritance of modifications acquired by
the individual. Because English children may inherit blue eyes and
flaxen hair from their Anglo-Saxon ancestors, it by no means follows
that an Englishman must inherit his father's sunburnt complexion or
smooth-shaven face. Of course atavism ultimately adopts many instances
of revolt against its sway. But to assume that these changes of type
_follow_ the personal change rather than cause it, is to assume the
whole question at issue. That like begets like is true as a broad
principle, but it has many exceptions, and the non-heredity of acquired
characters may be one of them.
FOOTNOTES:
[2] _Principles of Biology_, Sec. 166, footnote. The English jaws are
somewhat lighter than the Australian jaws, though I could not undertake
to affirm that they are really shorter and smaller. In the typical
skulls depicted on p. 68 of the official guide to the mammalian
galleries at South Kensington, the typical Caucasian jaw is very much
larger than the Tasmanian jaw, although the repulsively obtrusive teeth
of the latter convey the contrary idea to the imagination. Mr. Spencer's
assumption that the ancient Britons had large jaws appears to me
erroneous. (See Professor Rolleston's _Scientific Papers and Addresses_,
i. p. 250.)
[3] Romanes, Galton, and Weismann have made great use of this principle
in explaining the diminution of disused organs. Weismann has given it
the name of _Panmixia_,--_all_ individuals being equally free to survive
and commingle their variations, and not merely selected or favoured
individuals. See his _Essays on Heredity_, &c., p. 90 (Clarendon Press).
[4] Inclusive in each case of fixed strengthening wire weighing about a
sixteenth of an ounce or less.
[5] References of course are to _Factors of Organic Evolution_.
[6] P. 13; and _Nineteenth Century_, February, 1888, p. 211.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account