Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and DarwinBall, W. P. (William Platt)
Philosophy
Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and Darwin
Ball, W. P. (William Platt)
Heredity; Variation (Biology)
SHORTENED LEGS OF RABBITS.
In the case of the domestic rabbit Darwin notices that the bones of the
legs have (relatively) become shorter by an inch and a half. But as the
leg-bones have _not_ diminished in relative weight,[37] they must
clearly have grown _thicker_ or denser. If disuse has shortened them, as
Darwin supposes, why has it also thickened them? The ears and the tail
have been lengthened in spite of disuse. Why then may not the ungainly
hind-legs have been shortened by human preference independently of the
inherited effects of disuse? By relying on apparently favourable
instances and neglecting the others it would be easy to arrive at all
manner of unsound conclusions. We might thus become convinced that
vessels tend to sail northwards, or that a pendulum oscillates more
often in one direction than in the other. It must not be forgotten that
it would be easy to cite an enormous number of cases which are in direct
conflict with the supposed law of use-inheritance.
BLIND CAVE-ANIMALS.
Weak or defective eyesight is by no means rare as a spontaneous
variation in animals, "the great French veterinary Huzard going so far
as to say that a blind race [of horses] could soon be formed." Natural
selection evolves blind races whenever eyes are useless or
disadvantageous, as with parasites. This may apparently be done
independently of the effects of disuse, for certain neuter ants have
eyes which are reduced to a more or less rudimentary condition, and
neuter termites are blind as well as wingless. In one species of ant
(_Eciton vastator_) the sockets have disappeared as well as the eyes. In
deep caves not only would natural selection cease to maintain good
eyesight but it would persistently favour blindness--or the entire
removal of the eye when greatly exposed, as in the cave-crab--and as Dr.
Ray Lankester has indicated,[38] there would have been a previous
selection of animals which through spontaneous weakness, sensitiveness,
or other affection of the eye found refuge and preservation in the cave,
and a subsequent selection of the descendants whose fitness for relative
darkness led them deeper into the cave or prevented them from straying
back to the light with its various dangers and severer competition.
Panmixia, however, as Weismann has shown, would probably be the most
important factor in causing blindness.
INHERITED HABITS.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account