Very well. The Æolian people then caused that case to be appealed to the circuit court of appeals. When the case came up there I filed a petition in that court to be permitted to argue the case on behalf of the defendant, and also file a brief, both of which petitions were granted. In that petition I repeated the whole Æolian story over again, and I served a copy of that petition on Mr. Hughes a week before the argument came up, and he had abundant opportunity to reply to it. I also called him up and asked him if he was going to reply to it, and he said "No." And when he came to the argument he was as silent as the grave; though he had nearly two hours for his speech, he was as silent as was the grave in respect to all the allegations I had made about the inherent character of the Æolian scheme, and confined himself entirely to attempting to persuade the court that a perforated paper roll was an infringement of sheet music, and that however unconscientious the Æolian scheme might be as the representative of the Æolian company it was entitled to the pound of flesh. And that was the way he met the second presentation of the Æolian scheme. Afterwards, two weeks ago yesterday, the circuit court of appeals for the second circuit decided against him again. Mr. BONYNGE. How long ago? Mr. WALKER. Two weeks ago yesterday. Mr. CURRIER. The decision is in the record already. Mr. WALKER. Certainly. Now, I wish to say this to the committee, that that Æolian scheme is the most ingenious scheme that I ever knew to be invented by anybody in this country for the purpose of acquiring wealth by means of a patent or a copyright monopoly. And, further than that, I wish to say that the Æolian scheme is so ingenious that it does not violate any law whatever except one, and that is the golden rule. You can not square the Æolian scheme with the Sermon on the Mount, but you can square it with the Sherman antitrust act, and you can square it with every statute on the statute books. They have dodged a violation of every statute in inventing their scheme. And now they lack nothing at all to consummate their scheme except for Congress to pass this bill in the form in which it is drawn. That will place the capstone upon the monument, and will give to the Æolian Company a million of dollars a year out of the pockets of the people of the United States. And of that million of dollars they will keep at least $900,000, and about $90,000 of the rest will go to the music publishers, and not one cent over $10,000 of the whole million will go into the pockets of any music composers during their natural lives.