Aspects of scienceSullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Philosophy
Aspects of science
Sullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
English essays -- 20th century; Science
It is doubtless worth noting in this connection that Maxwell, unlike
most of the scientific men of his time, was genuinely interested in
metaphysical speculation. This was not merely another interest of
his; it was, at most, another field of attention; he brought the same
attitude of mind to all the objects with which he was concerned. We
cannot make an exception even in the case of his religious views; to
this man the problems of metaphysics, of physics, of morality, are
almost arbitrary divisions of the one object of his thought. He was
expressing a real difference from himself when he said that some men
seem to have water-tight compartments in their minds. When we study the
kind of homogeneity characteristic of Maxwell’s mental life it is easy
to understand those who call him a mystic. Even as a purely scientific
man, his rational faculty, as evidenced by his mathematical reasoning,
was a distinctly more fallible thing than his intuition. This is not to
say that he was not a fine mathematician, but it is his intuitive grasp
of a physical problem which gives him his high position, and not his
purely mathematical verifications. His mathematics, in fact, was not
always impeccable, as Sir Joseph Larmor points out in the new edition
of _Matter and Motion_. But it is characteristic of Maxwell, that,
even when his proofs were faulty, his results were usually sound. His
own way of confirming a difficult intuition was not to provide a formal
mathematical verification, but to make appeal to easier intuitions--in
fact, to construct mechanical models. He always liked to _see_ the
way things worked. It is important to remember that this desire for a
particular kind of verification was not due to any lack of power to
form abstractions; it was due to something quite different, to a lack
of ease when faced by a purely logical chain of deduction. On Maxwell’s
famous _Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism_, Poincaré comments
that its difficulty resides precisely in its great abstraction. It is
this presentation of his theory to which one has to turn; nevertheless
Maxwell, as if for his private satisfaction, developed some extremely
complicated models which seemed to him to make his theory clearer. It
was doubtless this combination, a great power of abstraction on the one
hand, and a desire for very definite, even unnecessarily definite,
confirmation on the other, which enabled him to be at once extremely
original and remarkably sound.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account