Aspects of scienceSullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Philosophy
Aspects of science
Sullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
English essays -- 20th century; Science
This aspect of Maxwell, as a critic at large, as it were, would
well repay study, and it is unfortunate that our material for it is
contained in a scarcely ideal biography. He differed from the run of
scientific men, whose absorption in one pursuit makes their mental life
unrepresentative; his chief problems are not found in his scientific
writings, and they are the problems of us all. There was nothing
superficial in Maxwell, and he had no easily won conclusions. It is
the path he followed that gives interest to his goal. We should like
to know, for instance, what experiences, what reflections, enabled him
to write: “Long ago I felt like a peasant in a country overrun with
soldiers, and saw nothing but carnage and danger. Since then I have
learned at least that some soldiers in the field die nobly, and that
all are summoned there for a cause.” That Maxwell, either suddenly
or gradually, developed a mystic consciousness of life, is borne
out by many passages of his correspondence. We can attach no other
significance to his description of his “nostrum”: “an abandonment of
wilfulness without extinction of will, but rather by means of a great
development of will, whereby, instead of being consciously free and
really in subjection to unknown laws, it becomes consciously acting by
law, and really free from the interference of unrecognised laws”; and
his letters to his wife, dealing with passages from the Bible, abound
in interpretations which are indubitably mystical. Yet we have no
evidence that he was acquainted with the literature and terminology
of mysticism; he is speaking of personal experiences, not of acquired
doctrines.
The maintenance of a mystical outlook on life, together with a
perfect realisation of the implications of physical science, was
accomplished, in Maxwell’s case, by denying the ordinary conception of
the _direction_ of scientific progress. It is the idea which would
inevitably occur to him, for it is the peculiar merit of his own work
that it was not the result of straightforward progress. He made a new
way of thinking necessary just as, in our own time, Quantum Theory and
Relativity Theory have fundamentally disturbed our most unquestionable
assumptions. The way Maxwell actually approached the problem we have
mentioned was by insisting on what he called, by a mathematical
analogy, the “singular points” of existences, that is, the points where
the equations break down, and he postulated that the more there were
of these singular points the higher the rank of the existence. At a
“singular point” influences which are usually negligible may assume a
dominating importance, and Maxwell saw the science of the future as
being largely concerned with these lapses in continuity--as, in fact,
science since his time has been. In this way he escaped determinism. In
his own words:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account