Aspects of scienceSullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Philosophy
Aspects of science
Sullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
English essays -- 20th century; Science
But, turning to the popular but accurate scientific article, we may ask
what purpose it serves. Should its object be to supply the deficiencies
of a defective general education, to provide an easy introduction
to science? Doubtless such articles or lectures have served such a
purpose; Faraday himself, as we know, was won over to science by the
blandishments of Mrs. Somerville, and there is more than one case where
the current of a man’s life has been definitely changed by a lantern
lecture. It is, nevertheless, a mistake to suppose that the attentive
perusal of a number of popular science articles is equivalent to a
scientific education, a mistake which is unfortunately very common. The
fact is that the scientific treatise and the popular science article,
so far from being rivals, serve entirely different ends, and may be
read with profit by the same man. Broadly speaking, the function of
the popular science article is to present science in its humanistic
aspect. It should, while dealing with as definite a scientific problem
as the author chooses, hint at the relations between this problem and
the other interests of mankind. Very often these relations are implicit
in the subject; such subjects are, in fact, usually chosen, and for
that reason. But there is another type of article which has for its
object the exposition of relations which are not obvious, and this
exposition may be the result of a genuine and valuable intellectual
effort on the part of the writer. Such articles are really essays in
criticism and are not essentially different from the best type of
literary criticism. Some of the best articles of this kind--some of
those by W. K. Clifford, for example--are as truly “research” work as
is the technical paper. A third type of article may, either by way
of history or by way of logic, show the position occupied by a given
theory or fact in a scheme of knowledge. This type is usually of more
interest to the scientific student than to the general reader, since a
general acquaintance with the whole subject is presupposed, and in this
connection it is interesting to note that a powerful plea has recently
been made for the more effective endowment of the teaching of the
history of science.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account