Socrates returns with Strepsiades, whom he can teach nothing. The Chorus
suggest he should bring his son to learn from Socrates how to get rid of
debts. At first Pheidippides refuses but finally agrees, though he warns
his father that he will rue his act. The Just and Unjust arguments
come out of the academy to plead before the Chorus. The former draws a
picture of the old-fashioned times when a sturdy race of men was reared
on discipline, obedience and morality--a broad-chested vigorous type. In
utter contempt the latter brands such teaching as prehistoric. Pleasure,
self-indulgence, a lax code of morality and easy tolerance of little
weaknesses are the ideal. The power of his words is such that the Just
Argument deserts to him.
Strepsiades, coached by his son, easily circumvents two money-lenders
and retires to his house. He is soon chased out by his son, who when
asked to sing the old songs of Simonides and Aeschylus scorned the idea,
humming instead an immoral modern tune of Euripides' making. A quarrel
inevitably followed; Strepsiades was beaten by his son who easily proved
that he had a right to beat his mother also. Stung to the quick the old
man burns the academy; when Socrates and his pupils protest, he tells
them they have but a just reward for their godlessness.
The Socrates here pilloried is certainly not the Socrates of history;
his teaching was not immoral. But Aristophanes is drawing attention
to the evil effects produced by the Sophists, who to the ordinary man
certainly included Socrates. The importance of this play to us is clear.
We are a nation of half-trained intelligences. Our national schools are
frankly irreligious, our teachers people of weak credentials. Parental
discipline is openly flouted, pleasure is our modern cult. Jazz bands,
long-haired novelists and poets, misty philosophers, anti-national
instructors are the idols of many a pale-faced and stunted son of
Britain. The reverence which made us great is decadent and openly
scoffed at. What is the remedy? Aristophanes burnt out the pestilent
teachers. We had better not copy him till we are satisfied that the
demand for them has ceased. A nation gets the instruction for which it
is morally fitted. There is but one hope; we must follow the genuine
Socratic method, which consisted of quiet individual instruction. Only
thus will we slowly and patiently seize this modern spirit of unrest;
our object should be not to suppress it--it is too sturdy, but to direct
its energies to a better and a more noble end.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account