Such is the _Iliad_. To modern readers it very often seems a little
dull. Horace long ago pointed out that it is inevitable that a long
poem should flag; even Homer nods sometimes. Some of the episodes are
distinctly wearisome, for they are invented to give a place in this
national Epic to lesser heroes who could hardly be mentioned if Achilles
were always in the foreground. Achilles himself is not a pleasing
person; his character is wayward and violent; he is sometimes childish,
always liable to be carried away by a fit of pettishness and unable to
retain our real respect; further, a hero who is practically invulnerable
and yet dons divine armour to attack those who are no match for him when
he is without it falls below the ordinary "sportsman's" level. Nor can
we feel much reverence for many of the gods; Hera is odious, Athena
guilty of flat treachery, Zeus, liable to allow his good nature to
overcome his judgment--Apollo alone seems consistently noble. More, we
shall look in vain in the _Iliad_ for any sign of the pure battle-joy
which is so characteristic of northern Epic poetry; the Greek ideal
of bravery had nothing of the Berserker in it. Perhaps these are the
reasons why the sympathy of nearly all readers is with the Trojans, who
are numerically inferior, are aided by fewer and weaker gods and have
less mighty champions to defend them.
What then is left to admire in the _Iliad_? It is well to remember
that the poem is not the first but the last of a long series; its very
perfection of form and language makes it certain that it is the result
of a long literary tradition. As such, it has one or two remarkable
features. We shall not find in many other Epics that sense of wistful
sorrow for man's brief and uncertain life which is the finest breath
of all poetry that seeks to touch the human heart. The marks of rude or
crude workmanship which disfigure much Epic have nearly all disappeared
from the _Iliad_. The characterisation of many of the figures of the
poem is masterly, their very natures being hit off in a few lines--and
it is important to remember that it is not really the business of Epic
to attempt analysis of character at all except very briefly; the story
cannot be kept waiting. But the real Homeric power is displayed in
the famous scenes of pure and worthy pathos such as the parting of
Andromache from Hector and the laments over his body. Those who would
learn how to touch great depths of sorrow and remain dignified must see
how it has been treated in the _Iliad_.
A few vigorous lines hit off the plan of the _Odyssey_.
"Sing, Muse, of the man of much wandering who travelled right far
after sacking sacred Troy, and saw the cities of many men and knew
their ways. Many a sorrow he suffered on the sea, trying to win a
return home for himself and his comrades; yet he could not for all
his longing, for they died like fools through their own blindness."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account