There was another stanza, but this is quite enough, which is what
Julius Benedict and Jenny Lind thought, for only those two stanzas
were set to music and sung. Bayard Taylor himself was not proud of his
effort. Both he and Richard Henry Stoddard, his best friend, competed
for the prize, because they both needed the $200. Taylor wrote to a
friend that his “only inspiration was the hope of getting the two
hundred dollars,” and the protests of the other competitors, coupled
with the knowledge that he had not written a good poem, made him regret
that he had ever yielded to temptation. He was worried about the
effect of the poem upon his reputation, and he told Stoddard before
the protests of the other competitors that he anticipated them because
two of the judges were his friends. Two months after the prize was
announced he wrote to Stoddard: “Did you see the Brooklyn announcement
of my lecture? (‘Bayard Taylor, the successful competitor of the Jenny
Lind prize.’) Is that song to be the only thing which will save my name
from oblivion?” It was not necessary for him to worry: his translation
of Goethe’s _Faust_ has outlived the “Welcome to America.”
William Allen Butler, author of “Nothing to Wear,” wrote a book of
parodies which went into three editions, called _Barnum’s Parnassus_,
purporting to be confidential disclosures of the Jenny Lind Prize
Committee. The following is the most interesting poem in the book:
A VOLUNTEER ODE
By the ‘Acknowledged Best Song Writer’--Not a Competitor
I
“Ho! all ye bards, from best to worst,
In village, town or city;
Hand in your Songs before the 1st
To Barnum’s Prize Committee!
“Ho! every charming poetess
Pick out your choicest ditty,
And send it on, post-paid--express--
To Barnum’s Prize Committee!
* * * * *
IV
“$200, cash! My eyes!
In _cash_, two hundred dollars!
Why, in the good old centuries
Your Spensers and your Wallers,
And those Elizabethan gents,
In ruffs, and beards and bonnets,
Were glad to get as many _pence_
For one of their short sonnets!”
* * * * *
The protesting poetical voices pleased Barnum immensely. He had offered
his $200 for a prize ode, and he received as well several hundred
letters of indignation written to the newspapers, a book of parodies,
in every one of which his name was mentioned several times, and a
reputation for generosity to poor literary men, who were also newspaper
men.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account