Bedouins: $b Mary Garden, Debussy, Chopin or the circus, Botticelli, Poe, Brahmsody, Anatole France, Mirbeau, Caruso on wheels, Calico cats, The artistic temperament; Idols and ambergris, with The supreme sin, Grindstones, A masque of music, and The vision malefic; with various portraits of Mary Garden in operatic costumeHuneker, James
History
Bedouins: $b Mary Garden, Debussy, Chopin or the circus, Botticelli, Poe, Brahmsody, Anatole France, Mirbeau, Caruso on wheels, Calico cats, The artistic temperament; Idols and ambergris, with The supreme sin, Grindstones, A masque of music, and The vision malefic; with various portraits of Mary Garden in operatic costume
Huneker, James
Garden, Mary, 1874-1967; Music -- History and criticism; Sopranos (Singers)
Debussy is the most interesting of contemporary music-makers and
the most subtle composer for the pianoforte since Chopin. His
originality is not profoundly rooted in the history of his art, but
his individuality is indisputable. He is a musician doubled by a
poet. He is almost as Gallic as Chopin is Polish. Debussy shows race.
His artistic pedigree stems from a grafting of old French composers
upon ultramodern methods. Wagner, Chopin, certain aspects of Liszt,
and Moussorgsky. The visit he made to Russia in 1879 had important
consequences. He read the manuscript score of Boris at Rome, he
absorbed Moussorgsky and the whole-tone scale, and this influence
contributed to the richness and complexity of his style. Above all, he
is a stylist. He has Wagner at his finger-tips, and, like Charpentier,
he can’t keep Tristan out of his music; it is his King Charles’s head.
Naturally such highly peptonized aural diet is not nourishing. Like the
poetry and prose-poems of Stéphane Mallarmé, too much Debussy becomes
trying to the nerves. Schumann has spoken of the singularly irritating
effect of muted dissonances. Pelléas is nearly all muted. The mental
and emotional concentration involved in the hearing of this music
fatigues as does no other music; not even Tristan.
The range of ideas, like the dynamic range, is limited. Yet there is
magic in his music, the magic of evocation. Not to describe, but to
evoke, in effortless imagery, is the quintessence of his art. He is
a painter of cameos and aquarelles. Never does he carve from the big
block; an exquisite miniaturist, he does not handle a bold brush, nor
boast the epical sweep of his predecessors; Berlioz for one. But he
is more intimate, he is the poet of crepuscular moods. The sadness of
tender, bruised souls is in his pages. Of virility there is little
trace, it is music of the distaff, and seldom sounds the masculine
ring of crossed swords. Chopin, too, had his nocturnal moments, but
he also wrote the A flat Polonaise, with its heroic defiance of a
Poland crushed yet never conquered; with its motto: “Jescze Polska nie
zginiela!”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account