Bell's Cathedrals: St. David'sRobson, Philip A. (Philip Appleby)
History
Bell's Cathedrals: St. David's
Robson, Philip A. (Philip Appleby)
St. Davids Cathedral
=The South Transept= still retains the outline of the arch of the great
south window which was blocked up when the four existing Perpendicular
windows of four lights each were inserted. A double buttress supports
the south-east corner of the transept, and behind this is the present
Chapter House.
=The East End.=--The south Presbytery aisle was put into proper repair at
the time of the general restoration, and new windows were inserted. The
upper tier of windows at the east end of the Presbytery have been well
restored also by Scott, and his own description[5] may well be given:
“In restoring the eastern arm of the church, a question arose
which, though but slightly suggested in my first Report, grew upon
my mind as we proceeded to such a degree, that it was more than a
twelvemonth before I could make up my mind as to which course to
take. The case was this:
“This wall of the church had originally side walls, much lower than
at present, with a high-pitched roof, and was constructed with
some view to stone groining, though it is clear that this was never
carried out, and was, in fact, deliberately relinquished.
“The east end had two ranges of windows, three most magnificent
lights below and four above.
[Illustration: SOUTH DOORWAY.]
“In the fifteenth century the high roof was taken off, the side
walls raised by the addition of some six feet of dead wall, the
gable lowered, and a very flat, though handsome roof placed upon
the walls thus altered; at the same time the upper tier of lancet
windows was removed, all but the outer jambs, and the space they
occupied converted into a single window in the Perpendicular style,
with a very flat arch.
“Sometime later still the three great lancet lights below were
walled up, owing to the erection of Bishop Vaughan’s chapel behind
them.
“Finding that the dead wall, thus added to the sides, was a
_perfect mine_ of the _débris_ of the ancient upper tier of
windows, that the Perpendicular window substituted for them was so
decayed as to require renewal, and that the timbers of the late and
low-pitched roof were much decayed, it was a tempting idea to
restore this limb of the church to its ancient design, and to add
groining (if not of stone, at least of oak) as at first
contemplated; while opposed to this was the judicious rule laid
down by Messrs. Freeman and Jones, the historians of the cathedral,
that when ancient alterations had become stereotyped as a part of
an historical monument, all change in them not included under the
term _restoration_ is set down as to be in itself reprehended, only
to be justified by special circumstances, the burden of proving
whose existence rests, in every case, with the innovator.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account