Franklin, Benjamin, 1706-1790 -- Juvenile literature
Barely was he settled when he was invited to visit Lord George
Grenville, president of the Privy Council and one of England’s most
important statesmen. This was Franklin’s first test in holding his own
with persons more steeped than he in political intrigue.
Lord Grenville received him with great civility, questioned him at
length about American affairs, and then announced that the colonists had
some erroneous notions he felt duty bound to correct:
“You Americans have wrong ideas of the nature of your constitution; you
contend that the King’s instructions to his governors are not laws, and
think yourselves at liberty to regard or disregard them at your own
discretion. You must be made to understand that the King’s instruction
are _The Law of the Land_.”
This was simply not true. The King’s instructions were laws in the
colonies only if they received the approval of the local Assembly. In
the same way, laws passed by a colonial Assembly had to be submitted to
the King before they became final. That was why Franklin was in England,
to get the King’s approval of the Assembly decision on the Penns.
Sure as he was of his facts, he voiced his opinion in the manner he had
learned from Socrates: “It is my understanding that ...”
“You are totally mistaken,” Lord Grenville stated patronizingly, when he
had finished.
It was Franklin’s first experience with the contemptuous attitude which
certain of the British took in regard to the colonists. He would later
observe that “every man in England seems to jostle himself into the
throne with the King, and talks of _our subjects_ in the colonies.”
Around the middle of August he called on the Penn family, at their
stately mansion in Spring Garden. It had seemed courteous to meet with
them personally before approaching higher authority. William Penn’s son
Thomas was there and probably Richard Penn and his son, John. They
received him with glacial politeness, listened haughtily as he told them
the Assembly’s grievances, and just as haughtily denied that the
grievances were in any way justified.
Franklin pointed out that the Assembly was asking no more than what
William Penn had promised citizens under his 1701 Charter of Privileges.
“My father granted privileges he had no right to grant, according to the
Royal Charter,” Thomas Penn announced.
“Then all those who came to settle in the province, expecting to enjoy
the privileges contained in the grant were deceived, cheated and
betrayed?” With the greatest difficulty, Franklin kept his voice calm.
Thomas Penn laughed insolently. “If the people were cheated, it was
their own fault. They should have gone to the trouble of reading the
Royal Charter.”
His tone reminded Franklin of a horse trader of low character, jeering
at the purchaser he had victimized. “Poor people are not lawyers,” he
said steadily. “They trusted your father and did not think it necessary
to consult a lawyer.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account