Yorkshire Herald { 6 selections (one “starred”) (Yorkshireman) { —all wrong. Yorkshire Press { 6 selections (one “special”) (Ivanhoe) { —2 right (_not_ the “special”). Result { 6 right. { 57 wrong. There are many examples of the inaccuracy of sporting tips in the evidence of the Select Committee on Betting. The best are given below:— REV. J. W. HORSLEY’S EVIDENCE (_a_) Manchester: out of 40 selected winners, not a single one was right. (_b_) Seven sporting papers gave 79 horses: in 74 cases their predictions were wrong. (_c_) Case of the _Standard_, which selected 179 horses for 148 races: 155 were wrong, and 24 right. (_d_) In 7 races the chief sporting papers gave in one week 45 horses, of which 40 were wrong; again, they gave 47 horses, of which only 1 was right. (_e_) In one month the chief sporting papers gave 898 horses for 156 races, out of which 777 lost.—_Vide_ p. 183 of Report. THE DUKE OF PORTLAND AND TIPSTERS The Duke of Portland sent £7: 14s. to thirteen sporting prophets. Four of these sent him 35 losers and 1 winner.—_Vide_ p. 186 of Report. VIII BIBLIOGRAPHY Anti-gambling Crusaders, A Hint to the Clergy, and. W. H. Norris. Anti-gambling League, Bulletin of the National. England. Backing, Certain Systems of. Sefton. Backing Horses, A Practicable System of. Brandon. Betting. G. Poste. Betting Club, Doncaster. W. Sheardown. Betting, The Law relating to. G. H. Stutfield. Betting and Gaming Houses, The Law affecting. L. Duckworth. Betting, A Talk with Young Men on. A. Rowland. Betting, Systematic. Its Use and Abuse. H. Betting, New System of. Metallic. Betting and Gambling. Student. Betting and Gambling. J. M. Hogge. Betting and Gambling. S. Churchill. Betting, Gambling, and the Bible. A. T. Barnett. Betting, Handbook of. Mathematician. Betting, Tattersall’s Rules on. G. H. Stutfield. Blot on the Queen’s Reign. J. Hawke. Calculator, Jonathan’s. Card-Sharping Exposed. J. E. Robert-Houdin. Card-Trick Exposed, The Three. Chance and Luck. R. A. Proctor. Devil’s Picture Books. Van Rensselaer. Form, The New Book of. E. Chilton. Gambling, History of, in England. J. Ashton. Gambling World, Anecdotes, Memories, and Stories. “Rouge et Noir.” Gambling and Betting. H. H. Chamberlain. Gambling Sinful? Is. H. J. Tebbutt. Gambling. E. C. Chorley. Gambling, Is it Wrong? J. M. Lambert. Gambling, A Talk on. A. Rowland. Gambling. W. J. S. Smith. Gambling, Ethics of. W. D. Mackenzie. Gambling, The Law of. W. Coleridge and C. V. Hawksforth. Gambling Communities. A. Hepner. Gambling Games of the Chinese in America. S. Culin.