Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecast — John Shaqi
Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecastBlacker, C. P. (Charles Paton)
Philosophy
Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecast
Blacker, C. P. (Charles Paton)
Birth control
When the effects of all this upon the children are considered, it is at
once found that the question of Birth Control is intimately connected
with the housing problem. The overcrowding in large slum families is
notorious. At an early age the day is passed by these children in
the street, where, filthy and untended, they receive little by way
of notice from their elders except hard words or blows. Their nights
are spent packed, in a fetid atmosphere, several together in the same
bed from which they may witness their parents in sexual intercourse,
sometimes their mother in labour, and where they are free to indulge
in what, later in life, would be called incestuous practices with one
another. The writer has on more than one occasion attended a woman in
confinement while several children were watching her from a bed in the
same room, there being, in the urgency of the situation, no time to
dispose of them and nowhere immediately available to send them.
* * * * *
Substantially this is what has been said on each side of this complex
question.
Before proceeding to discuss the arguments heretofore propounded, it is
necessary to emphasize the fact that from the technical point of view
_a really satisfactory contraceptive does not yet exist_.
The chief disadvantage attaching to the contraceptive used by the man
is that it is quite impossible to induce the type of individual whose
procreation we would wish to restrict to use any contraceptive at all.
The child is usually begotten by such a parent when he is drunk, and
everyone who has had experience of the conditions prevailing in bad
slums will know that it is futile to expect to achieve anything along
these lines through the man. The problem must be met through the
woman who, unlike the man, has to put up with the discomfort and the
pain of repeated pregnancies, and has to shoulder the main burden of
large families. Were it not for this elementary human fact all attempts
to teach Birth Control to the very poor and destitute would fail
completely.
Essentially, contraceptives which the woman can use are of two sorts,
and involve two principles――namely, a mechanical or occlusive, and a
chemical or spermicidal principle.
The objections to the first are two, namely that they are far from
being fool-proof, and that unless sanctioned by a doctor their use can
be followed by serious harm. It will be clear to any medical man that
for a patient suffering from gonorrhœal cervicitis, or indeed from
any condition involving a chronic cervical discharge, the use of an
occlusive pessary may lead to disastrous consequences. The broadcasting
of promiscuous advice as to the utilization of these objects in the
absence of an examination by a competent medical man or woman is
therefore to be strongly condemned.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account