Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecastBlacker, C. P. (Charles Paton)
Philosophy
Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecast
Blacker, C. P. (Charles Paton)
Birth control
The militancy of Mohammedanism will probably have little effect on the
future of the world, because Mohammedan countries are at present poorly
organized for extensive modern war. The Church of England is more
concerned with the social and international implications of religion
than any other, and the above remarks have little relevance to it.
If, therefore, the cataclysm above contemplated is to be averted
the first necessity would seem to be a revision of the standards of
existing religions, in consideration of the unification of the human
race, so as to accord with a formula of something of this sort: That
is good and morally right which will promote the general happiness and
goodwill of humanity, and the harmony of the world. It is clear that
action leading to the limitation of over-multiplication would in this
sense be good and in accordance with religion.
* * * * *
The second obstacle to the realization of a control of population is
the standard by which the merit of a nation is now generally appraised,
and to which most nations aspire. This merit is largely estimated in
terms of power of offence and defence. This is a bad criterion and
should be altered for a better one which will now be considered.
Earlier in the book reference was made to a biological argument against
contraception, consideration of which was deferred. This argument holds
that in so far as reproduction is a primary biological function, a
thwarting of that function is not only unnatural but anti-biological.
This view has a certain plausibility but does not stand close scrutiny.
The criterion of biological value or fitness is essentially racial, not
individual. That is biologically good which will improve or benefit the
race, that is bad which will harm or weaken it.
Under stable conditions of racial equilibrium there is a reasonable
expectation that instincts and structures which have had survival value
in the past will continue to have such value in the future. But during
moments of crisis, at those turning points in the history of living
things when new forms appear, such a presumption is quite unjustified.
Thus if we picture to ourselves, allegorically, an event which probably
took many thousands of years to accomplish, we might imagine the
comments of a conservative piscine critic upon the emergence of the
first Dipnoid from some muddy river on to land.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account