Birth control laws : $b shall we keep them, change them, or abolish themDennett, Mary Ware
History
Birth control laws : $b shall we keep them, change them, or abolish them
Dennett, Mary Ware
Birth control; Birth control -- Law and legislation -- United States
“Suppose there were a public meeting in your district, Mr. X, and
you stood before an audience of your own constituents, and told
them that you believed that most of the young folks were better off
ignorant than with knowledge on this subject, because they couldn’t
withstand the temptation to misuse it, and so the laws that tried to
keep them from knowing were good laws. Then suppose someone else were
standing beside you, saying just the reverse, another Congressman who
might say, ‘My dear young friends, I believe in you. I know you are
human, with all the impulses that sway live people, and I know that
some people are swayed when they ought not to be, but I believe the
majority have the strength of mind and character to go right, even
if they do know how to go wrong and cover it up, and so I am against
all laws that try to keep knowledge away from you.’ Which man do you
think would get the response of the audience?”
“Oh, of course it would be the one who said he believed in them,
that’s natural. They would want to believe in themselves, too, but
think how it would be that night, when the young girl goes out with
the boy, and she can’t help thinking, what difference will it make
if nothing ever shows? And then she will forget all about character,
and will let herself go, whereas if she was afraid of the practical
results, she wouldn’t. Yes, there are thousands of girls that are
held back just that way.”
Then I asked if he didn’t know that there was such a lot of
contraceptive knowledge in circulation—and most of it bad too—that
the number of girls that could be protected by their ignorance was
diminishing every hour, and that there was absolutely no effort
at enforcement of the laws? He said people argued that way about
enforcing the prohibition laws, but he thought it ought to be
enforced and could be. He insisted he was “just being practical,
that’s all.” I insisted that I was the more practical, as I had faith
in knowledge and strength which were dynamic, and not in just fences,
which are dead. “Well, you certainly are a pretty talker, Mrs. D——
and I may be wrong. Of course, if you can convince me....” “I don’t
think I can convince you, but I think you can convince yourself, if
you make a business of turning your face toward the light instead of
to the darkness.”
“Well anyhow, you think what would happen in all these government
boarding houses over here,” pointing out the window to the wartime
buildings which still house hundreds of women clerks, “a lot of them
are confirmed old maids too, but I wouldn’t trust what would happen
to them, if they all knew they could do what they pleased and no one
would be the wiser.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account