“It is scarcely necessary,” says Mr Rellstab, in the preface to an early
edition of his romance of “1812,” “for the author to confess how largely
he has availed himself of Ségur’s narrative of the Russian campaign. It
will be evident to all readers that he has followed, at times almost
word for word, the descriptions of that skilful historian.” Without
taxing Mr Rellstab with exceeding the romance-writer’s legitimate
privilege in thus largely helping himself from the pages of General
Count Ségur, we may congratulate him on having had as a guide, in the
historical portions of his book, so admirable a work as the _Histoire de
Napoleon et de la Grande Armée_. As interesting as any romance, it at
the same time conveys the conviction that the author has determined to
merit the character of historian, and to avoid that of the retailer of
campaigning gossip and anecdotes. Indeed one often feels disappointed
and almost vexed at the extreme brevity with which the Count refers to
all matters not strictly essential to the history of the grand army and
great chief whose history, during the brief existence of the former and
the first reverses of the latter, he undertakes to portray. He dismisses
in three lines many an incident of strange romance or thrilling horror,
whose details one would gladly see extended over as many pages. Mr
Rellstab has cleverly availed himself of this dignified and military
conciseness, improving upon hints, and filling up blanks. With a few
bold dashes of his graphic pen, Count Ségur furnishes the rough sketch;
this his German follower seizes, adds figures, tints, and names, and
expands it into a picture. The account in “1812” of the retreat from
Moscow to Wilna is, in fact, a poetical paraphrase of that given in
Ségur’s history; and this paraphrase Mr Rellstab, seduced by the
excellence of his text, allows somewhat to impede the progress of his
plot; or rather it protracts the book after the plot has, in all
essential respects, been wound up. Nevertheless, as we have already
said, this paraphrase, which may be considered in some degree
supplementary or parenthetical, is the best part of the work; and Mr
Rellstab displays great power of pen, and artistical skill, in his
handling and adaptation of the materials furnished by his French leader.
The last strictly original chapters of the romance are those composing
the eleventh book, commencing immediately after Ludwig is rescued by
hostile peasants from death at the hands of his own friends. Here for a
while we lose sight of the fugitive army, and abide amongst the
Russians.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account