Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 66 No.406, August 1849Various
General
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 66 No.406, August 1849
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
"And, some time after, he startled me by a prayer that I would
permit him, with his father's consent, to accompany you to
Australia. The only answer I have given him as yet, has been in
the form of a question: 'Ask yourself if I ought? I cannot wish
Pisistratus to be other than he is; and unless you agree with him
in all his principles and objects, ought I to incur the risk that
you should give him your knowledge of the world, and inoculate him
with your ambition?' He was struck, and had the candour to attempt
no reply.
"Now, Pisistratus, the doubt I expressed to him is the doubt
I feel. For, indeed, it is only by home-truths, not refining
arguments, that I can deal with this unscholastic Scythian, who,
fresh from the Steppes, comes to puzzle me in the Portico.
"On the one hand, what is to become of him in the Old World? At
his age, and with his energies, it would be impossible to cage him
with us in the Cumberland ruins; weariness and discontent would
undo all we could do. He has no resource in books--and I fear
never will have! But to send him forth into one of the overcrowded
professions--to place him amidst all those 'disparities of social
life,' on the rough stones of which he is perpetually grinding
his heart--turn him adrift amongst all the temptations to which he
is most prone--this is a trial which, I fear, will be too sharp
for a conversion so incomplete. In the New World, no doubt, his
energies would find a safer field; and even the adventurous and
desultory habits of his childhood might there be put to healthful
account. Those complaints of the disparities of the civilised
world, find, I suspect, an easier if a bluffer reply from the
political economist than the Stoic philosopher. 'You don't like
them, you find it hard to submit to them,' says the political
economist; 'but they are the laws of a civilised state, and you
can't alter them. Wiser men than you have tried to alter them,
and never succeeded, though they turned the earth topsy-turvy!
Very well; but the world is wide--go into a state that is not so
civilised. The disparities of the Old World vanish amidst the
New! Emigration is the reply of Nature to the rebellious cry
against Art.' Thus would say the political economist: and, alas,
even in your case, my son, I found no reply to the reasonings! I
acknowledge, then, that Australia might open the best safety-valve
to your cousin's discontent and desires; but I acknowledge also a
counter-truth, which is this--'It is not permitted to an honest
man to corrupt himself for the sake of others.' That is almost the
only maxim of Jean Jacques to which I can cheerfully subscribe! Do
you feel quite strong enough to resist all the influences which a
companionship of this kind may subject you to--strong enough to
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account