The remark to which we have alluded is this: that the work before us is pervaded by a tone of uniform, excessive, and undistinguishing _eulogy_, which, however creditable to the amiable and generous dispenser of it, is calculated to lower our estimate of his critical judgment, and even--unless one should be on one's guard--to provoke a harsh and disparaging spirit towards the subjects of such undue eulogy, and a suspicion that here "praise undeserved," and the remark is applicable equally to praise "excessive, is censure in disguise!" No judge, no counsel, can say or do _anything_, in the course of any of the trials here brought under our notice, without speaking and acting in such a way as to merit applause for exhibiting the highest qualities of mind and character. Let it not be supposed, that, in making these observations, we wish to apply them to the particular instances cited by Mr Townsend of Messrs Whiteside, Cockburn, and Talfourd--all of whom are distinguished, accomplished, able, and eloquent advocates; but we believe that each would, in spite of the fondest self-love, in his own mind, somewhat mistrust his title to the _amount_ of applause here bestowed upon him. What more than he has said of them, could he have said of the greatest orators and advocates whom the world has produced? In a corresponding strain, Mr Townsend speaks of every one--senior and junior counsel--and every writer, great and small, whom he has occasion to mention. Those who knew the late Mr Townsend, and appreciated his simple and manly character, will refer the defect which we have felt compelled thus to point out to its true cause--the kindliness of his heart; and we believe that, had he lived to see these observations, his candour would have caused him promptly to recognise their justice. Each of the trials is preceded and followed by "Introductory Essays" and "Notes."