Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 70, No. 431, September 1851Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 70, No. 431, September 1851
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
"When it was proposed some twenty years ago to extend the
franchise to the metropolitan boroughs, the presumption was,
that the quality of the representatives would bear something
like a proportion to the importance of the constituencies
called into play. In other words, if the political axioms from
which the principle of an extended representation is deduced
have any foundation in reality, it should follow that the most
numerous and most intelligent bodies of electors would return
to Parliament members of the highest mark for character and
capacity. Now, looking at the condition of the metropolitan
representation as it stands at present, or as it has stood any
time since the passing of the Reform Bill, has this expectation
been fulfilled? Lord John Russell, the First Minister of the
Crown, sits, indeed, as member for the city of London, and so
far it is well. Whatever difference of opinion may exist as to
the noble lord's capacity for government, or whatever may be the
views of this or that political party, it is beyond all dispute
that, in such a case as this, there is dignity and fitness in
the relation between the member and the constituency. But,
setting aside this one solitary instance, with what metropolitan
borough is the name of any very eminent Englishman associated at
the present time? It is of course as contrary to our inclination
as it would be unnecessary for the purposes of the argument, to
quote this or that man's name as an actual illustration of the
failure of a system, or of the decadence of a constituency. We
would, however, without any invidious or offensive personality,
invite attention to the present list of metropolitan members,
and ask what name is to be found among them, with the single
exception we have named, which is borne by a man with a shadow
of a pretension to be reckoned as among the leading Englishmen
of the age?"
You see, Provost, I am by no means singular in my estimate of the
quality of the metropolitan representatives. The _Times_ is with
me, or was with me twelve months ago; and I suppose it will hardly
be averred that, since that time, any enormous increase of wisdom
or of ability has been manifested by the gentlemen referred to.
But there is rather more than this. In the article from which I am
quoting, the writer does not confine his strictures simply to the
metropolitan boroughs. He goes a great deal further, for he attacks
large constituencies in the mass, and points out very well and
forcibly the evils which must inevitably follow should these obtain
an accession to their power. Read, mark, and perpend the following
paragraphs, and then reconcile their tenor--if you can--with the
later proposals from the same quarter for the general suppression of
small constituencies, and the establishment of larger tribunals of
public opinion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account