Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
This passage is very suggestive in two ways. In the first place, we
humbly venture to think that it contains many excellent reasons why the
ladies of America should mitigate their inordinate desire for sharing in
what hitherto have been considered the appropriate employments of men.
It appears, by Mrs Stowe’s evidence, that they have already so much
domestic work to perform, that they are compelled to sacrifice both
their health and beauty, which certainly are the two last things that a
woman would be inclined to part with. Therefore it seems to us unwise,
and even preposterous, that any portion of them should be clamorous in
demanding a further increase of duty, unless, like the gude-wife of
Auchtermuchty in the old Scots ballad, they are prepared to make an
entire interchange of occupation with their husbands, and can persuade
the latter to whip cream, concoct soup, wash the dishes, and arrange the
table, whilst they are pleading at the bar, prescribing for half the
young fellows in the neighbourhood, gesticulating at public meetings, or
receiving the incense of deputations. In the second place, these
particulars of American society may, in reality, have more to do with
the evident dislike to emancipation of the slaves which evidently
prevails in many parts of the United States, than Mrs Stowe was aware of
when she penned the passage. If it is true that the ladies of
America—using the term in the same sense as Mrs Stowe does, for she is
comparing the personal appearance of women of the richer and more
independent class in the two countries—if it is the fact that the
American ladies in the free States have to undergo the drudgery which
she describes, and that not from choice, but from absolute inability to
obtain proper assistance; then we have a distinct and intelligible
motive assigned to us why many excellent and humane people in the slave
States hesitate to join the movement in behalf of emancipation. We have
often suspected that some strong social reasons, unknown to us and to
the British public, must exist, to account for the continuance of the
slave system; and we think that Mrs Stowe has, albeit unwittingly,
disclosed one of them. For what does her sentiment amount to, but an
acknowledgment that, in the great enlightened republic of America, it is
impossible to procure decent or permanent service—that, as there is no
acknowledgment of anything like rank or gradation, the servants consider
themselves in all respects as good as their master or mistress, will not
obey them unless it suits their humour, and are always ready to decamp?
That must be the case, unless we are to suppose that the American
ladies, answering to the aristocracy here, have a diseased appetite for
performing the offices of scullion, cook, and table-maid. Now, it may be
thought a very strong statement on our part, but we venture to say, that
were slavery existing at the present time in Great Britain, and were the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account