Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
kind of free service procurable on any terms, no better than that which
Mrs Stowe and all other writers have described as existing in America,
emancipation would be a decidedly unpopular proposal in these Islands.
Is it possible to doubt that? Look at the history of the Factories Bill,
opposed, defeated, and evaded in every possible way, by the very same
men who proclaim themselves as the warmest friends of the negro. They
thought it as nothing that the bodies and souls of the young children
within their factories should be distorted and uncared for, whilst at
the same time they were ready to expend their gratuitous sympathy on the
American slave. But we shall not refer solely to them. Our remark
applies to every class; and we put the question to the ladies of this
country, from the Duchess of Sutherland downwards, whether, if they had
been born slave-owners, they would at once have relinquished their
control over those whom they could treat kindly, and whose affections
they could secure, to pass to a system which would have sent them down
from the drawing-room to slave themselves in the pantry or the kitchen?
Is that an argument for slavery? Heaven forbid! We intend nothing of the
kind, and should be very sorry to see our meaning so twisted and
distorted. But it is an argument of the very strongest description
against republicanism and republican institutions, and against those
absurd notions of equality which, under philosophical cover, are making
such rapid progress in this country. Slavery, we are convinced, has in
all times existed rather as a social necessity, than from any abstract
wish in man to own property in man. The idea is of itself repugnant. Not
much more than a hundred years ago, the Earls of Sutherland were, in
effect, considerable serf-owners. The patriarchal rule of the chief was
more despotic than is the sway of the proprietor of slaves in America;
for if the Mhor-ar-chat, which we apprehend to be the most ancient
designation of the family, had desired Dugald or Donald to pitch his
recusant brother into the loch, with some hundred-weight of granite
attached to his neck by a plaid, “nae doubt the laird’s pleasure suld be
obeyed.” Fortunately we are past that phase of existence. The feudal
system has decayed and died, which we are not by any means sorry for;
but, on the other hand, we have not yet arrived at the point when the
descendants of Dugald and Donald consider themselves as ranking in the
same degree of the social scale with the great Lady of Dunrobin. Feudal
service has given way to a better-ordered, more convenient, and more
profitable system. But still, among us, the gradations of rank are
recognised and acted on; and it is because the feelings and institutions
of the country are essentially aristocratic, that our domestic
arrangements and social intercourse are so decidedly superior to those
of America, or indeed of any other country in the world. We have equal
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account