Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 93, No. 570, April, 1863 — John Shaqi
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 93, No. 570, April, 1863Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 93, No. 570, April, 1863
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
difficult to substitute an open system, secret diplomacy is attended
with grave inconveniences, for it becomes impossible to furnish that
public who sit, as it were, in appeal, with the whole facts of the case
upon which they are called to decide. It is then clearly the interest of
the Foreign Office to encourage the dissemination of accurate political
information in a popular form, when the publication of it does not
involve a breach of confidence; and inasmuch as Blue-Books are not
generally considered light or agreeable reading, and are somewhat
inaccessible, the diplomatist who has a political story to tell, and can
do it without betraying State secrets, is a public benefactor. In these
days of official responsibility, it is not only due to the public but to
himself that he should have an opportunity of stating his case. It may
happen that his conduct will be brought publicly in question and decided
upon before he has an opportunity of laying before the world all the
facts. Great injustice is frequently done to officials serving in
distant parts of the world, who even at last are unable to remove the
erroneous impressions formed upon incorrect or insufficient information.
This has been specially the case in China and the East: a policy based
upon an acquaintance with the local conditions as intimate as it was
possible for a foreigner to obtain, has been upset by a majority of
ignorant legislators, who too often receive their impressions from
superficial travellers, or residents with special interests at stake. It
is clear that the opinion of a merchant is not so likely to be right in
diplomatic questions as that of a trained official, who has passed half
his life in studying the language, institutions, and people of the
country to which he has been accredited; yet when it comes to be a
question between the mercantile community and the minister, the latter
is in danger of going to the wall.
While, on the one hand, the traditions of the Foreign Office are opposed
to what may be termed diplomatic literature—and they dole out their own
information with a somewhat niggard hand—the British community resident
in the East, hampered by no such restraints, and aided by a scurrilous
press, may prejudice the public mind at home to such an extent that no
subsequent defence is of much avail. We cannot wonder then, if, after
five-and-twenty years’ experience of China and Japan, Sir Rutherford
Alcock should take the opportunity of giving a full, true, and
particular statement of the political difficulties by which he is
surrounded, in anticipation of a crisis which he sees impending, which
no diplomacy will be able to avert, but in which he will on his return
probably find himself involved.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account