Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 93, No. 571, May, 1863Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 93, No. 571, May, 1863
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
Nevertheless, Narrative necessitates so high a stretch of imagination,
and so wide a range of intellect, that it will always obtain, if
tolerably well told, a precedence of immediate popularity over the most
exquisite productions of an inferior order of the solid and staple
qualities of imagination—so much so that, even where the first has
resort to what may be called the brick and mortar of prose, as compared
with the ivory, marble, and cedar of verse, a really great work of
Narrative in prose will generally obtain a wider audience, even among
the most fastidious readers, than poems, however good, in which the
imagination is less creative, and the author rather describes or
moralises over what is, than invents and vivifies what never existed.
The advantage of the verse lies in its durability. Prose, when appealing
to the imagination, has not the same characteristics of enduring
longevity as verse;—first and chiefly, it is not so easily remembered.
Who remembers twenty lines in ‘Ivanhoe’? Who does not remember twenty
lines in the ‘Deserted Village’? Verse chains a closer and more minute
survey to all beauties of thought expressed by it than prose, however
elaborately completed, can do. And that survey is carried on and
perpetuated by successive generations. So that in a great prose fiction,
one hundred years after its date, there are innumerable beauties of
thought and fancy which lie wholly unobserved; and in a poem, also
surveyed one hundred years after its publication, there is probably not
a single beauty undetected. This holds even in the most popular and
imperishable prose fictions, read at a time of life when our memory is
most tenacious, such as ‘Don Quixote’ or ‘Robinson Crusoe,’ ‘Gulliver’s
Travels’ or the ‘Arabian Nights.’ We retain, indeed, a lively impression
of the pleasure derived from the perusal of those masterpieces; of the
salient incidents in story; the broad strokes of character, wit, or
fancy; but quotations of striking passages do not rise to our lips as do
the verses of poets immeasurably inferior, in the grand creative gifts
of Poetry, to those fictionists of prose. And hence the Verse Poet is a
more intimate companion throughout time than the Prose Poet can hope to
be. In our moments of aspiration or of despondency, his musical thoughts
well up from our remembrance. By a couple of lines he kindles the
ambition of our boyhood, or soothes into calm the melancholy
contemplations of our age.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account