Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine — Volume 54, No. 333, July 1843Various
General
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine — Volume 54, No. 333, July 1843
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
It has been asserted by some that salmon will dwell continuously, and
even breed, in fresh water, although debarred all access to the sea.
"Near Kattrineberg," says Mr Lloyd, in his work on the field-sports of
the north of Europe, "there is a valuable fishery for salmon, ten or
twelve thousand of these fish being taken annually. These salmon are
bred in a lake, and, in consequence of cataracts, cannot have access to
the sea. They are small in size, and inferior in flavour. The year 1820
furnished 21,817." We confess we cannot credit this account of fresh
water (sea-debarred) salmon, but suppose there must be some mistake
regarding the species. Every thing that we know of the habits and
history, the growth and migrations, of these fish in Britain, is opposed
to its probability. Mr Young has conclusively ascertained that, at least
in Scotland, not only does their growth, after the assumption of the
silvery state, take place solely in the sea, but that they actually
decrease in weight from the period of their entering the rivers; and Mr
Scrope himself, (see pp. 27, 30,) although he quotes the passage without
protest, seems of the same opinion. Besides, with their irrepressible
instinctive inclination to descend the rivers during spring when young,
we don't believe that the cataract in question would prevent their doing
so, although it might assuredly hinder their return in summer, in which
case the Kattrineberg breed would soon become extinct, even supposing
that they had ever had existence. The alleged fact, however, is well
worthy of more accurate observance and explicit explanation than have
yet been bestowed upon it by the Scandinavian naturalists.
We are informed that Mr George Dormer of Stone Mills, in the parish of
Bridport, put a female salmon, which measured twenty inches, and was
caught in the mill-dam, into a small well, where it remained twelve
years, and at length died in the year 1842. "The well measured only five
feet by two feet four inches, and there was only fifteen inches depth of
water." We should have been well pleased to have been told of the size
of the fish when it died, in addition to that of the prison in which it
dwelt, for otherwise the fact itself is of less consequence.[13] We
presume its rate of growth would be extremely slow, although we do not
agree with Mr Young in the opinion already quoted, that salmon actually
decrease in _dimensions_ on entering the fresh water. We doubt not they
decrease in _weight_, and probably also in circumference; but their
bones and organic structure are assuredly enlarged, and themselves
lengthened, in such a way as to fit their general form for a rapidly
increased development, so soon as they again rejoice in the fattening
influences of the salubrious sea.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account