Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 57, No. 354, April 1845Various
General
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 57, No. 354, April 1845
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
receives advantage by this lopping of his superfluous branches, but I
rejoin that a translator has no such right. When a painter copies
from the life, I suppose he has no privilege to alter features and
lineaments, under pretence that his picture will look better: perhaps
the face which he has drawn would be more exact if the eyes and nose
were altered; but it is his business to make it resemble the
original. In two cases only there may a seeming difficulty arise;
that is, if the thought be notoriously trivial or dishonest; but the
same answer will serve for both, that then they ought not to be
translated--
'Et qua
Desperes tractata nitescere posse, relinquas.'
"Thus I have ventured to give my opinion on this subject against the
authority of two great men, but, I hope, without offence to either of
their memories; for I both loved them living, and reverence them now
they are dead. But if, after what I have urged, it be thought by
better judges that the praise of a translation consists in adding new
beauties to the piece, thereby to recompense the loss which it
sustains by change of language, I shall be willing to be taught
better, and recant. In the meantime, it seems to me that the true
reason why we have so few versions which are tolerable, is not from
the too close pursuing of the author's sense, but because that there
are so few who have all the talents which are requisite for
translation, and that there is so little praise, and so small
encouragement, for so considerable a part of learning."
We could write a useful commentary on each paragraph of that lively
dissertation. The positions laid down are not, in all their extent,
tenable; and Dryden himself, in other places, advocates principles of
Translation altogether different from these, and violates them in his
practice by a thousand beauties as well as faults. We confine ourselves to
one or two remarks.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account