Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 64, No. 393, July 1848 — John Shaqi
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 64, No. 393, July 1848Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 64, No. 393, July 1848
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
It has been said that no further legislative enactment is required
in Ireland, and that administrative wisdom must do what yet
remains to be done. Mr Jackson, however, shows that there are such
deep-seated evils in Ireland as cannot be cured except by the direct
interference of the legislature. But we think he expects too much
from the Sale of Encumbered Estates Bill. An extensive change of
proprietorship would, we are persuaded, be a great evil in Ireland.
There is an attachment in general to the "ould stock" among their
poorer neighbours, which would naturally be followed by a jealousy
and prejudice against the new comers who displaced them. And this
prejudice would of itself neutralise any efforts for improvement
which the landlord might otherwise be disposed to make--although,
in most cases, we should not expect much effort in this direction
from a stranger mortgagee, often an unwilling purchaser, who would
naturally be anxious to contract with those parties from whom he
could obtain his rents with least trouble, leaving them to deal with
the land as they liked, and thereby continuing and increasing the
odious middleman system.
Mr M'Culloch does not confine his examination of the compulsory
partition in France to its influence on agriculture. He has
discerned certain political effects of that and the concomitant
system of which it is a part, with a precision which subsequent
events have elevated into a sort of prophecy. The preface to his
work is dated December 1847, and the work was published, we believe,
early in January. There can, therefore, be no grounds for classing
the following passage with those anticipations which are made after
the event:--
"The aristocratical element is no longer to be found in French
society; and the compulsory division of the soil, while it
prevents the growth of an aristocracy, impresses the same
character of mobility upon landed possessions that is impressed
on the families of their occupiers. Hence the prevalent want of
confidence in the continuance of the present order of things in
France. What is there in that country to oppose an effectual
resistance to a revolutionary movement? Monarchy in France has
been stripped of those old associations and powerful bulwarks
whence it derives almost all its lustre and support in this
and other countries. The throne stands in solitary, though not
unenvied dignity, without the shelter of a single eminence,
exposed to the full force of the furious blasts that sweep
from every point of the surrounding level. There is nothing
intermediate, nothing to hinder a hostile majority in the
Chamber of Deputies from at once subverting the regal branch of
the constitution, or changing the reigning dynasty."--P. 132-133.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account