Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 71, No. 436, February 1852Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 71, No. 436, February 1852
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
has remarked, Sir George's _Marlborough Despatches_ constitute a
work of inestimable importance to the historian, and also to the
military reader; but they will rarely, if ever, be opened by the
general reader. We ourselves have turned from its pages, more than
once, hopelessly, with yet a feeling that they contained matter
of great interest and importance to a competent and determined
military or historical reader. This is Mr Alison's first and richest
mine, sunk in his own country. In quest of another he crosses the
Channel, and there encounters the _Military Life of Marlborough_,
in three volumes, written in France in 1807, at the instance of
his mighty admirer, Napoleon:[8] "towards the composition of
which," says Sir George Murray, "every facility of information
was afforded which the power of the Emperor could command." This
Mr Alison pronounces "the best military narrative of the Duke's
exploits which has yet appeared." But Mr Alison is indebted to
France for another grand source of authentic information on "the
Continental side of the great wars waged by Marlborough"--General
_Pelot's_ Collection of original Memoirs and Despatches, published
in nine quarto volumes, and entitled, "_Mémoires Militaire Rélatifs
à la Succession d'Espagne_." Again, we have the _Dutch_ account
of this ever-memorable war, published at the Hague in 1721--the
"magnificent work" of _Rousset_, in three volumes folio. And yet
again, _Kausler's_ "admirable summary of great battles, collected
from the best authorities, and annexed to his splendid military
Atlas." To these must be added, Archdeacon Coxe's _Life_, in three
volumes quarto--"the most authentic and valuable which exists,"
founded on a close examination of all the correspondence known to be
in existence at the time; but liable to a serious drawback--that "it
is long and expensive, and too full of long documents, and letters,
_in the text_." What are all these works, exclaims the embarrassed
general reader, to _me_?--having neither time, nor inclination, nor
means for mastering them? You might as well place a man seeking
for a richly-chased golden goblet in the midst of the Californian
or Australian gold-fields, and point him with exultation to piles
of sacks filled with the auriferous dust! Now Mr Alison has, in
the two moderate-sized volumes before us, presented the impatient
applicant with his desired goblet, and entitled himself thereby to
due gratitude. He is scrupulous in owning his obligations, and also
in enabling his reader at once, if disposed, to verify facts, and
extend his inquiries, by placing at the end of every paragraph, as
in his _History of Europe_, the authorities on which that paragraph
is founded. To these are added a very carefully-prepared map of
France and the Netherlands, "so arranged as to show the positions of
every place, in strict accordance with the text;" and plans of the
battles, accurately reduced from the great German work of Kausler,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account