Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 71, No. 437, March 1852Various
General
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 71, No. 437, March 1852
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
"The first time," she says, "I ever met with any of his works,
this vagueness brought me into a ludicrous dilemma. It was in
the great library of Tavistock House that Mr Perry one morning
put into my hand a splendidly printed and splendidly bound
volume, (_Alastor_, as I think,) and desired me to read it, and
give him my opinion. 'You will at least know,' he said, 'whether
it be worth anybody else's reading.'
"Accordingly I took up the magnificent presentation copy, and
read conscientiously till visitors came in. I had no marker,
and the richly-bound volume closed as if instinctively; so that
when I resumed my task, on the departure of the company, not
being able to find my place, I was obliged to begin the book
at the first line. More visitors came and went, and still the
same calamity befell me; again, and again, and again I had to
search in vain amongst a succession of melodious lines, as like
each other as the waves of the sea, for buoy or landmark, and
had always to put back to shore and begin my voyage anew. I do
not remember having been ever in my life more ashamed of my own
stupidity, than when obliged to say to Mr Perry, in answer to
his questions as to the result of my morning's studies, that
doubtless it was a very fine poem--only, that I never could
tell, when I took up the book, where I had left off half an hour
before--an unintended criticism, which, as characteristic both
of author and reader, very much amused my kind and clever host."
Now, if, instead of the magnificent presentation copy, read in the
great library of Tavistock House, where visitors were coming in
and going out, Miss Mitford had taken a little homely manageable
volume down Woodcock Lane, and there read _Alastor_, undisturbed,
beneath the shadow of the trees, she must, we think, have had to
record a very different impression of the poem. She would have
needed no "marker." Perhaps there would have lived in her memory an
hour of intellectual pleasure as great as any that the page of the
poet had ever procured for her. Though not the highest effort of
Shelley's genius, _Alastor_ is probably the most pleasing. There is
no tortuosity of thought to pardon or to forget; it is one unbroken
interwoven strain of music, of imagery, of sentiment. Those who have
defined poetry as the luxury of thought, could nowhere find a better
example to illustrate their meaning--it is all music, imagination,
feeling. Oh, when the summer months come round, let us entreat
Miss Mitford _to try it in Woodcock Lane_! How could she trust to
anything she had read out of a magnificent presentation copy, in the
great library at Tavistock House?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account