"On the 2d July," continues Orme, "we marched to Jacob's Cabin,
about 6 miles from the camp." Notice the words "from the camp." The
preceding stop was then a _bivouac, not a camp_. The camp referred
to was the encampment one mile on the east side of the Youghiogheny,
at Stewart's Crossing. This day's march would be about one mile, and
the place of encampment Jacob's Cabin. The two halting places were
evidently both on the east side of Jacob's Creek. What is commonly
known as the Great Swamp Camp was only the bivouac to which reference
has been made.
This view of the matter seems, however, not to have been taken by any
of the cartographers: but in estimating the value of maps one must, of
course, consider whether the author's first-hand knowledge, as well
as his borrowed data, be trustworthy or not, and must also take into
account the purpose for which the map was made. Professor Channing
has pointed out among other things that, while "a lie in print is
a persistent thing," one on a map is even less eradicable, and for
three reasons: (1) because the historical evidence on maps is liable
to error, and an error once made is copied by other cartographers,
with the result that a false impression frequently continues
through centuries; (2) because the topography is often wholly
wrong, especially on the earlier maps, a fact that is too commonly
overlooked by historians; (3) because, as our own national history has
abundantly proved, boundaries are frequently delineated imperfectly,
inaccurately, and without basis in fact. In a word, Professor Channing
thinks that maps are often taken too seriously, that the historical
information given by them is liable to error, and that they simply
raise a presumption.
It is certainly true that, judged by the exceedingly accurate and
reliable journal of Orme, the map accompanying Sargent's _History of
an Expedition against Fort Du Quesne_ (op. 282) is in almost every
instance wholly inaccurate in regard to the location of Braddock's
camps, which it represents as scattered promiscuously along the route.
In scarcely a single respect, indeed, whether as to route or as to
location of camps, mountains, rivers, or anything else, can it be
depended upon. To cite a single instance, it puts Camp 6 (Bear Camp)
on the Youghiogheny, when this, as we have seen, is the location of
Squaw's Fort (see p. 23). No clue to the authorship of this map or to
any authority for it can be discovered. Similar fallacies occur in the
work of one of our latest historians, E. M. Avery, who in his _History
of the United States and its People_ (Cleveland, 1904, IV. 67) also
prints a beautifully-colored but inaccurate map. Judge Veech, too (in
his _Monongahela of Old_, 61), recognizes an apparent inconsistency in
Orme's journal at this point; but, like the others, he only adds more
fuel to the flame of confusion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account