This combination of succession and juxtaposition is implied, moreover,
in the Pāḷi word, _paccayā_, used to express the connecting together
of the separate links. Verbally correct and true to the meaning, the
Causal Chain would be translated as follows:--
“Ignorance must be present in order that Tendencies may come to
pass. Tendencies must be present in order that Viññāṇa may come to
pass;--which latter here signifies Consciousness as passing-over Kamma;
for this passing-over Kamma does not admit being spoken of otherwise
than in the form of consciousness. This passing-over Kamma must be
present in order that the fashioning of a new Individuality may come
to pass. This latter must be present in order that a referring back
of all the Six Kinds of Sense-Impressions to myself may come to pass.
This must be present in order that Contact, an approaching on my part
to things whether physical or mental, may come to pass. Contact must
be present in order that Sensation, this in order that Craving, this
in order that Clinging, this in order that the perpetually repeated,
new upspringing of the _I_-process may come about which here is
disintegrated in the stage of Passing-over (Bhava) and the final result
(Jāti),[14] the Coming-into-manifestation of a new Kammic impulsion
_within_ this my personality; whereupon the last link follows as a
natural consequence.”
The Causal Chain is the best touchstone by which to test whether a
person is really capable of following the Buddha-thought or not. If he
is incapable of doing so, he comes by a sad fall at the “violation” of
the law of contradictories which follows from _Jāti_ being taken as
_Birth_ in the grossly vulgar acceptation of the word; and cannot make
out how an individual who has long since been active as such, should
only subsequently be “born.”
The other absurdity which necessarily arises when one interprets the
links in the vulgar sense as a following after one another of cause and
effect, is this: that in this case Ignorance is installed as a sort of
blind end, and so the way is opened for the introduction of all sorts
of cosmological speculations to which our men of learning are only the
more inclined that they generally come from Sanskrit to Pāḷi, or, what
in substance amounts to the same thing, from the Upanishads to the
Suttas.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account