Burmah and the BurmeseMackenzie, Kenneth R. H. (Kenneth Robert Henderson)
History
Burmah and the Burmese
Mackenzie, Kenneth R. H. (Kenneth Robert Henderson)
Burma -- Civilization; Burma -- History
The Burmese code, in its various aspects, seems most strangely inapposite
for the land in which it is placed; or, it might be more correct to
say, for the officers by whom it is dispensed. The police magistrate’s
position is in Europe a responsible and disagreeable one; but the case
is far otherwise in Burmah, and indeed in all Oriental governments
having native ministers. For, though there may be amongst them some few
scrupulous men, yet, as a whole, we cannot look upon the magisterial
office as otherwise than an engine of extortion, and as a means whereby
to turn the weaknesses of the human disposition to the best advantage. It
is, however, not very remarkable that a country should exist with good
laws and bad administrations, as it is not impossible for a nation to
continue under the rule of obsolete ordinances and quibbling sinecurists.
Many of the grievances are, however, chargeable on the inactive and
unenergetic disposition of the people. I am not, however, prepared, with
all this, to go the length of Crawfurd, who thus speaks:[47]—
“The police is as bad as possible; and it is notorious that in all times
of which we can speak with certainly, the country has been overrun
with pirates and robbers. Responsibility is shifted from one person to
another, and a general ignorance and want of intelligence pervades every
department.[48] It is a matter well known, however contrary to theory,
that in consequence of this state of things even a royal order will often
fail of commanding respect or attention at the distance of five short
miles from the seat of government.”
These are but broad, sweeping assertions, like those exactly
contradictory remarks of Symes, quoted at the close of the last chapter;
and such broad assertions must ever be received _cum grano salis_. A
middle path between these two must be taken. The condition of the country
is probably no worse, and no better, than in the neighbouring empire
of China, where the same iniquitous system of bribery prevails amongst
the magistracy, and where the actual amount of crime is not great in
proportion to the population and extent of the country. The envoy of a
government is not likely in the quick progress of his passage through
the country, to be able to examine into the condition of the people
impartially, and, as they are prepared to make the best or the worst show
they can to the foreign ambassador, so, too, will the foreign ambassador
take the best or the worst view of their character.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account