Callinicus : $b A defence of chemical warfareHaldane, J. B. S. (John Burdon Sanderson)
Philosophy
Callinicus : $b A defence of chemical warfare
Haldane, J. B. S. (John Burdon Sanderson)
Chemical warfare; Gases, Asphyxiating and poisonous -- War use
survivors of lung-irritant gases would get consumption, while those
burned by mustard gas would develop cancer. This has not happened, but
it is the sort of rumour that easily starts.
For, after all, our greatest weapon in chemical warfare is not gas,
but education, and education of all classes. By education I mean a
process which puts people in general in touch with the thought of the
abler minds of their own and past times, whether in literature or art,
in science, mathematics, or music. An educated man knows enough of
science, for example, to be able to distinguish a gas from a smoke,
or a Grindell-Matthews from a Marconi, even if he is not thoroughly
versed in the kinetic theory of gases or the laws governing radiation
through the ether. Educated men are rather rare. It will be worth
while giving some examples of how our uneducated politicians and
soldiers failed to adjust themselves to the scientific thought of their
contemporaries.
In April, 1915, a relatively educated member of the Government got
hold of a physiologist, whose name I suppress as he is a modest man.
He found a rather curious state of affairs. On the _Emden_, a German
cruiser captured in the Indian Ocean, a German sailor had been found in
possession of a pad of lint with tapes to tie in front of his mouth. It
did not even cover his nose, and, though it might or might not have
been of some value against smoke, it was of none at all against gas.
There was, however, a very prevalent belief at that time, and may be
still, for all that I know, that German men of science were vastly
superior to British. It is perfectly true that there are more of them,
but I think that their average attainments in the last forty years have
been, if anything, slightly below those of our own. So hypnotized,
however, were some of the authorities in this country by this theory
that it was being proposed to issue these articles to our troops. After
pointing out their uselessness, the physiologist in question was rushed
over to France in a destroyer, along with a chemist. He identified the
gas used by the Germans as chlorine. On his return, he got a cylinder
of that gas, let some into an air-tight chamber, and devised a rough
respirator which would keep most of it out, trying various possible
methods on himself. On his return to the War Office, rather short
of breath from the chlorine he had breathed, he found to his horror
that the appeal to the women of England for home-made respirators had
been issued. Their design was apparently based on the captured German
one, which had very probably been made on the _Emden_. As they were
quite useless, he secured a promise that they would not be sent out
to France. Things were not made easier by the opinion held in high
military quarters that, offence being more important than defence, the
great thing was to reply to the Germans by gassing them. As, however,
this could not be done in less than five months, while respirators
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account