Capital punishment among the Jews : $b a paper read before the New York Board of Jewish MinistersPool, David de Sola
Religion
Capital punishment among the Jews : $b a paper read before the New York Board of Jewish Ministers
Pool, David de Sola
Capital punishment (Jewish law)
From one passage[124] it would seem that in later Rabbinic times, (c.
350 C. E.), when the penalty of death for murder could no longer be
imposed by the Jewish court, it was recommended that the death sentence
be commuted into one of blinding the murderer. When it was reported
that Bar Chama had committed a murder, the Exilarch bade Rab Abba (or
Acha) bar Jacob investigate the case. If it proved that Bar Chama
was guilty, his eyes should be put out.[125] But this passage stands
alone, and does not allow us to draw any conclusion as to a general
practise. Moreover the expression “to put out his eyes” may possibly be
figurative, meaning imposing a fine or taking away authority.[126]
We see, therefore, that the necessity of adhering to the express
commands of the Torah prohibited the Rabbis from commuting a death
sentence into scourging, imprisonment, blinding or any other kind of
mutilation, exile, enslavement, a fine or any other punishment. The
exact words of the Torah had to be upheld.
Therefore, while rigidly maintaining the Biblical principle of capital
punishment, the Rabbis availed themselves of their right to modify the
_method_ of executing the death sentence. If they upheld the death
penalty, there was nothing to prevent their mitigating the severity of
its application in every way possible. We have already seen how stoning
was modified in practise to precipitation, and burning modified to
strangulation followed by a nominal burning. Our consideration showed
that these changes in method apparently came about in order to secure
the easiest and most humane methods of death, (since according to the
golden rule even the condemned criminal is one’s brother), and in order
to spare the body, so far as possible, all mutilation or disfigurement.
The general principle governing the lightening of the methods of death
was that wherever the Torah does not specify which method of death is
to be employed, the easiest and most humane method is to be used.[127]
Legal Restrictions
But the most thoroughgoing modification of the system of capital
punishment was not brought about through change in the methods of
imposing the death penalty, but through surrounding the accused with
so many legal safeguards that it became virtually impossible ever to
impose a death sentence.
The law limited the right of trying capital cases to the high tribunal
of twenty-three, not even the king having the right to put to death
other than through the Sanhedrin.[128] According to Rabbinical
tradition, one very large class of capital cases was taken out of
the jurisdiction of any human court, namely those in which the Bible
stipulates _Kareth_ or Excision as the punishment. This ruling at one
stroke absolved the Rabbinical courts from the obligation of imposing
the death sentence in a large number of cases.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account