Now to summarise the main points of my thesis. In my opinion there have
been several mistakes committed by the students of Caste, which have
misled them in their investigations. European students of Caste have
unduly emphasised the rôle of colour in the caste-system. Themselves
impregnated by colour prejudices, they very readily imagined it to be
the chief factor in the Caste problem. But nothing can be farther from
the truth, and Dr. Ketkar is correct when he insists that “All the
princes whether they belonged to the so-called Aryan race, or the
so-called Dravidian race, were Aryas. Whether a tribe or a family was
racially Aryan or Dravidian was a question which never troubled the
people of India, until foreign scholars came in and began to draw the
line. The colour of the skin had long ceased to be a matter of
importance.”⁷ Again, they have mistaken mere descriptions for
explanation and fought over them as though they were theories of origin.
There are occupational, religious, etc. castes, it is true, but it is by
no means an explanation of the origin of Caste. We have yet to find out
why occupational groups are castes; but this question has never even
been raised. Lastly they have taken Caste very lightly as though a
breath had made it. On the contrary, Caste, as I have explained it, is
almost impossible to be sustained: for the difficulties that it involves
are tremendous. It is true that Caste rests on belief, but before
belief comes to be the foundation of an institution, the institution
itself needs to be perpetuated and fortified. My study of the Caste
problem involves four main points: (1) That in spite of the composite
make-up of the Hindu population, there is a deep cultural unity. (2)
That Caste is a parcelling into bits of a larger cultural unit. (3) That
there was one Caste to start with. (4) That classes have become Castes
through imitation and excommunication.
⁷ _History of Caste_ p. 82.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account